Jump to content

Would a Katy Perry Greatest Hits album eat?


Recommended Posts

Posted
14 minutes ago, Breathe On Moi said:

not the Lorde stan (love ya) trying to talk about one album with hits..

they're not related topics, who i stan doesn't change which artist i can criticize... :confused:

 

and also if that's the drag Royals is bigger than any Katy song in USA. 2013's most streamed female album is still Pure Heroine and not PRISM.

 

most importantly for new music i genuinely think Lorde is a bigger name than Katy in 2024... even her most underrated, non-mainstream release Solar Power did better numbers than 143 with no CDs, no bundles, no 843984 signed copies and the "music box" release not even counting towards Hot 200 — 57K vs. 48K :rip:

  • Thumbs Down 1

Posted (edited)

the greatest hits would end at Dark Horse.

she would benefit more from a Best Of rather than a Greatest Hits

Edited by Vixen Eyes
  • Confused 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

they're not related topics, who i stan doesn't change which artist i can criticize... :confused:

 

and also if that's the drag Royals is bigger than any Katy song in USA. 2013's most streamed female album is still Pure Heroine and not PRISM.

 

most importantly for new music i genuinely think Lorde is a bigger name than Katy in 2024... even her most underrated, non-mainstream release Solar Power did better numbers than 143 with no CDs, no bundles, no 843984 signed copies and the "music box" release not even counting towards Hot 200 — 57K vs. 48K :rip:

This is not true. Roar is the highest certified female song of all-time in the US, 15x Platinum. Royals is 14x Platinum.

 

  • Thanks 1
Posted
1 minute ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

This is not true. Roar is the highest certified female song of all-time in the US, 15x Platinum. Royals is 14x Platinum.

 

ok so what... should i give you a platinum certification for this :rip: Lorde's latest RIAA update is from 2023 and Katy updated hers 3 months ago it's normal that there's a 1x difference :toofunny2:

  • Thumbs Down 1
Posted
19 minutes ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

they're not related topics, who i stan doesn't change which artist i can criticize... :confused:

 

that's literally ATRL in a nutshell, don't play lol. It's lighthearted, not that serious. 

Posted
Just now, Breathe On Moi said:

that's literally ATRL in a nutshell, don't play lol. It's lighthearted, not that serious. 

same as my Teenage Dream joke :heart:

Posted

As a physical media collector, I think this would be a cool idea for some artists to do. Vinyl is not cheap and I don't really want to buy whole albums for artists that I really only like the singles from. I'd consider getting a KP GH album, even if I don't really care for her sonically and personally nowadays.

 

I know that GH albums are generally supposed to span all their albums, but that last one is a sneak

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

It would!  Even though Greatest Hits have kind of become outdated, I hope they make a comeback with how a few people have done vinyl only releases.

Posted
1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

LIFETIMES

spacer.png

Posted

So basically a mix of her first two albums + Roar/Dark Horse?

Posted (edited)

she could do a #1's album maybe pad it out with a remix or two.

she could remove Firework and call it "Dr. Luke Presents: Katy Perry" 

:ryan3:

 

Edited by popmusicisdead
  • Haha 2
  • Thumbs Down 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, popmusicisdead said:

she could do a #1's album maybe pad it out with a remix or two.

she could remove Firework and call it "Dr. Luke Presents: Katy Perry" 

:ryan3:

 

"Dr. Luke Presents:"

 

I am ******* dead 

 

Motherfkking Katy Gottwald

Posted

They won't do that now. They just released that fancy Box set with the first three album and also repressed them separately. Now it's time for them to repress Witness in some fun colour variant. Smile already had many variants do I don't think they have to bother with that. I'd say they could do Lifetimes collection that will line up with the end of the tour next year and include tracks from this era too. But honestly, GH albums are kind of pointless nowadays so they better save the money and keep it for her next album. 

Posted

so it would just be singles from teenage dream and prism??

 

thats lackluster 

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.