base talk Whose RedOne songs aged the worst?

[Josh]

Gaga:

"Boys Boys Boys"

"Just Dance"

"LoveGame"

"Money Honey"

"Paper Gangsta"

"Poker Face"

"Alejandro"

"Bad Romance"

"Monster"

"So Happy I Could Die"

"Hair"

"Judas"

"Scheiße"

"Gypsy"

"Angel Down"

"Angel Down" (work tape)

 

Nicki:

"Automatic"

"Starships"

"Pound the Alarm"

"Whip It"

 

JLo:

"On The Floor ft. Pitbull"

"Papi"

"Invading My Mind"

"Hypnotico"

"Charge Me Up"

"Dance Again ft. Pitbull"

"Live it Up ft. Pitbull"

 

 

[tost1]

Nicki's and JLo's equally. Gaga's are on a completely different level.

[tost1]

JLo was kinda shameless trying to recreate On The Floor twice with same producer AND feature. Dance Again was a bop though.

[motherpills]

nicole scherzinger

[secretgarden]

JFLOP

[lillavend3r]

Nicki's without a doubt. JLo's are dated as well but don't sound as dated cause Nicki's have those aggressive drops 

[QueenB]

that starships drop aged like milk 

[Human Fly]

The way Gaga dropped redone like a rock after he worked with nicki and jlo 

[popstyle]

lady gaga. Alejandro is the only song id listen to today.

[DonnaSpring]

Jlos but all are bops and none of them really aged badly 

[Le Grande]

None of them sound that good these days to me, but Pound The Alarm is one of the worst cases of an assault on ears so Nicki it is.

[TiaTamera]

I chose Jill only cause Nicki has Whip It and I use it till this day.

 

4 minutes ago, Le Grande said:

None of them sound that good these days to me, but Pound The Alarm is one of the worst cases of an assault on ears so Nicki it is.

I loathe this song 

[yonsé]

j.lo

[helpthomas]

it's crazy what gaga could make that man do. how did he work on Hair simultaneously as he worked on those J.Lo songs? did he intentionally give other people literal scraps and demos unless they were creatively involved in the process? lmao

[Arthoe]

44 minutes ago, helpthomas said:

it's crazy what gaga could make that man do. how did he work on Hair simultaneously as he worked on those J.Lo songs? did he intentionally give other people literal scraps and demos unless they were creatively involved in the process? lmao

Correct, pretty much every J.Lo song he worked on were Gaga rejects/scraps  

[BlondGuts]

Nicki are bad but she has whip it so I'm voting JLo

[Big Bad Wolf]

J.Lo easily. Those Gaga songs are iconic and even though they're from a specific era they're still great pop songs with an identity.

[Flanders]

Honestly a lot of these songs still slaps. So many guilty pleasures 

[Xtripped]

Nicki easily

[Nightingale]

Besides OTF and maybe even Papi and Dance Again, JLo's were pretty dated even at the time

[VioletsandRoses]

Hmm I bop to all of them but yeah Gaga's aged better. Still OTF, Dance Again, Whip It and pound the alarm are mega bops