Digitalism Posted September 27 Posted September 27 (edited) Harlequin is having a shaky start Will LG7 suffer the same luck? It seems Gaga lost her touch Edited September 27 by Digitalism 4 1 3 36
Popular Post Jay07 Posted September 27 Popular Post Posted September 27 If the entire album sounded like The Joker/Happy Mistake it would be universally acclaimed. It's the basic ass covers that drag it down. 24 1
fememeist Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Tbh she hasn't made a great album this past decade, and I say this with much adoration for her discography. Chromatica was a shell of what she could've done 6
Space Cowboy Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Gaga is uncapable of good albums, so no she can't lol 15 2 5 3 28
Cruel Summer Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Feels like saying this after a few reviews for an album that's been clearly demonstrated to be a side project is jumping the gun. I have full faith she can make something critically acclaimed and it won't be at all surprising if LG7 is that album since her most recent mainstream pop release did well with critics. Dawn of Chromatica did fine, too. 1 1
Digitalism Posted September 27 Author Posted September 27 Just now, Cruel Summer said: Feels like saying this after a few reviews for an album that's been clearly demonstrated to be a side project is jumping the gun. I have full faith she can make something critically acclaimed and it won't be at all surprising if LG7 is that album since her most recent mainstream pop release did well with critics. Dawn of Chromatica did fine, too. Are we acting like gaga is always acclaimed. She never had good reviews. TFM and BTW were only acclaimed retrospectively 1 13
SoJro101 Posted September 27 Posted September 27 I want this for her so bad. She's talented - it's always been the execution/vision over the past decade that's been the issue imo. Hopefully she'll get there, she seems to be inspired at the moment. 2
EnigmaticAndroid Posted September 27 Posted September 27 (edited) Critics rarely ever acclaim traditional pop albums anymore amd there was no reason to think this was going to break from that. Mid to upper 60s or low 70s was to be expected and is the range it's been getting. For what it's worth, Chromatica, despite the takes on here that it's a terrible album, got a 79 on MC so there's no reason to think that she simply can't get an 80+. We'll see what happens in the future. Edited September 27 by EnigmaticAndroid 9
Popular Post Spicy Pisces Posted September 27 Popular Post Posted September 27 7 minutes ago, Digitalism said: It seems Gaga lost her touch 1 minute ago, Digitalism said: She never had good reviews Pick a side! 6 15 8
Lady Claire Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Gaga is a polarizing figure, even if she makes a masterpiece some losers will give her 40s and 60s anyways. Her 13 Grammys and her Oscar are fine on her shelf though, and there's more to come. A proof that metascores are useless if you're winning outside of that 6
Digitalism Posted September 27 Author Posted September 27 3 minutes ago, Spicy Pisces said: Pick a side! Do you know how to read? She only had retrospective acclaim 1 2 2
WildHeart Posted September 27 Posted September 27 2 minutes ago, Lady Claire said: Gaga is a polarizing figure, even if she makes a masterpiece some losers will give her 40s and 60s anyways. Her 13 Grammys and her Oscar are fine on her shelf though, and there's more to come. A proof that metascores are useless if you're winning outside of that How many of these Grammys and Oscars were for her albums 1 1 4 3
jesus del rey Posted September 27 Posted September 27 1 minute ago, Digitalism said: Sabrina had an 82 with a super basic albums. Stop the excuses So the critics are untrustworthy you mean? 5 1
NoAngelus Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Gaga is benefiting from amazing PR machinery and poptism so even tho numbers will say yes, quality won't be there. She simply never made acclaimed album, even when she was the most inspired. 3 14
Nicholai Posted September 27 Posted September 27 3 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: Critics rarely ever acclaim traditional pop albums anymore amd there was no reason to think this was going to break from that. Mid to upper 60s or low 70s was to be expected and is the range it's been getting. For what it's worth, Chromatica, despite the takes on here that it's a terrible album, got a 79 on MC so there's no reason to think that she simply can't get an 80+. We'll see what happens in the future. 1 minute ago, Digitalism said: Sabrina had an 82 with a super basic albums. Stop the excuses 1
Kimmo Posted September 27 Posted September 27 (edited) We all know critics don't like Gaga and she pen that on Applause. These are the same critics who will Praise other artists for sampling and taking credit writing, producing etc… But when it comes to Gaga, they'll dissect everything and come up with an excuse of why they didn't like it. She is always held at high standards, That's what happens when you're A THREAT! Edited September 27 by Kimmo 1 7 3
Lady Claire Posted September 27 Posted September 27 1 minute ago, WildHeart said: How many of these Grammys and Oscars were for her albums Literally every era by her sans BTW and ARTPOP won a Grammy and every single project sans ARTPOP got noms? 2
jesus del rey Posted September 27 Posted September 27 1 minute ago, WildHeart said: How many of these Grammys and Oscars were for her albums 5 of them are for her albums, next time do quick Google search 1
Digitalism Posted September 27 Author Posted September 27 Just now, jesus del rey said: So the critics are untrustworthy you mean? But you can trust them to give Gaga bad reviews 1
jesus del rey Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Just now, Digitalism said: But you can trust them to give Gaga bad reviews This shows biases on their side and just makes their opinions less relevant
Nicholai Posted September 27 Posted September 27 (edited) 5 minutes ago, WildHeart said: How many of these Grammys and Oscars were for her albums 6/13 Edited September 27 by Nicholai
Gottasadae Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Oh wait, so metascore is useless when it coming to Gaga but very respected on ATRL when it's Katy or other girlies to bash them through the mud 3 2 5
WildHeart Posted September 27 Posted September 27 3 minutes ago, jesus del rey said: 5 of them are for her albums 1 minute ago, Nicholai said: 6/12 So what is the truth
Mr. Stratus Posted September 27 Posted September 27 17 minutes ago, Digitalism said: Harlequin is having a shaky start Will LG7 suffer the same luck? It seems Gaga lost her touch Britney and Madonna never made one so Gaga will be fine 1 1
Recommended Posts