base talk Should Billie stop directing her own videos?

[Megan Pete]

 

 

 

 

most of her videos are low effort and always are just one basic scene and often dont even match the aesthetics of the song. should she start hiring professional music video directors?

 

 

[Strawberry Bubble]

please, she's really not good at it

[Sannie]

How are YOU going to tell the person who wrote the song that HER aesthetics don't fit HER song? Please, go outside. Why is it so hard for pop stans to understand that sometimes an artist wants control of their art? Have you ever had something you cared about that you wanted to control?

Edited September 27 by Sannie

[Funnyfatty]

What the f does she know about cameras

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Maybe she should ask Finneas for help like she does for countless other things

[Digitalism]

Yes but doesn't this apply to everybody?

I don't know any pop girl that can actually direct.

All too well was cute but everything else taylor directed was mid.

Gaga's videos look cheap. The drop in quality was huge the moment she and haus started directing

 

 

Edited September 27 by Digitalism

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

Yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes 

[Megan Pete]

1 minute ago, Sannie said:

How are YOU going to tell the person who wrote the song that HER aesthetics don't fit HER song? Please, go outside. Why is it so hard for pop stans to understand that sometimes an artist wants control of their art? Have you ever had something you cared about that you wanted to control?

I can say so because I have eyes and ears? What type of authoritarian world are you living in where one can't have opinions on art? Not everyone can write or produce or direct and that's fine. If you still do it and you suck at it then don't be surprised when people voice their opinions

[Megan Pete]

3 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

Yes but doesn't this apply to everybody?

I don't know any pop girl that can actually direct.

All too well was cute but everything else taylor directed was mid.

Gaga's videos look cheap. The drop in quality was huge the moment she and haus started directing

 

 

Both of them are still better than Billie. But yes everyone agrees they should hire their old directors back. Or be like Beyoncé and only co-direct with someone

[Kyoto]

8 minutes ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

Maybe she should ask Finneas for help like she does for countless other things

And then you get mad when we call solar power nuclear waste.

Edited September 27 by Kyoto

[bad guy]

Well yes, but luckily we have the Guess remix video to save the visuals for this era

[LovingDays]

That's really the BOAF video...? That is not at ALL what I envisioned the video would be like. 

At least you can tell she studied the greats.

[Digitalism]

37 minutes ago, Megan Pete said:

Both of them are still better than Billie. But yes everyone agrees they should hire their old directors back. Or be like Beyoncé and only co-direct with someone

That's what they all should do if they want to be involved.

The reality is that they just don't know about the more technical aspects. Directing is not just having ideas for the videos

Edited September 27 by Digitalism

[Kayseri Mantisi]

1 minute ago, Kyoto said:

And then you get mad when we call solar power nuclear waste.

Reported for being off-topic. What I said is objectively true and she has said the exact same thing several times, you should know that better than anyone else as a stan. Aren't they almost acting like a musical duo at this point? Since she gets songwriting and producing tactics from him I thought she can get some hints about visuals too.

[Kyoto]

9 minutes ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

Reported for being off-topic. What I said is objectively true and she has said the exact same thing several times, you should know that better than anyone else as a stan. Aren't they almost acting like a musical duo at this point? Since she gets songwriting and producing tactics from him I thought she can get some hints about visuals too.

You know damn well what are you doing, but different from you I'm not a weak ***** that reports anything negative about my fave or that tries to act brand new about their behavior.

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Just now, Kyoto said:

You know damn well what are you doing, but different from you I'm not a weak ***** that reports anything negative about my fave or that tries to act brand new about their behavior.

You're a weak ***** that fumes 3 seconds after reading the name of Finneas in a thread about Billie

[yonsé]

she didn't even direct her latest video.

 

this guy did https://www.instagram.com/aidanzamiri/

[brraap]

Imagined BOAF video being her running around in a field of flowers with the sun shining 

 

wrf is this paranormal activity budget shite Billie 

[aesthetic bih]

Yes, she has a pattern of directing videos involving only 1-2 scenes

 

I was expecting a story-type video with a plot similar to Everything Has Changed lol

[illia]

LUNCH mv is kinda cute idk

Fits the song

[BrokenMachine]

It's her own music, she can do whatever she wants with it 

[50thStateofMind]

she can do whatever she wants but that video was not good for such an amazing song.

[MonsterTown]

yes please. 

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

1 hour ago, Sannie said:

How are YOU going to tell the person who wrote the song that HER aesthetics don't fit HER song? Please, go outside. Why is it so hard for pop stans to understand that sometimes an artist wants control of their art? Have you ever had something you cared about that you wanted to control?

How are YOU going to tell the person who wrote this thread that THEIR ideas don't fit THEIR thread? Please, go outside. Why is it so hard for pop stans to understand that sometimes an ATRL-er wants control of their thread? Have you ever had something you cared about that you wanted to control?

[sweetblindness]

The hat and glasses are doing her no favors I fear