suburbannature Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Must have three or more reviews. Any surprises? Janet - 7.8 (Damita Jo) Mariah Carey - 7.3 (Merry Christmas Deluxe Anniversary Edition) Adele - 7.3 (25) Billie Eilish - 6.8 (Hit Me Hard and Soft) Lady Gaga - 6.7 (Dawn of Chromatica) Megan Thee Stallion - 6.6 (Megan) Ariana Grande - 6.5 (Yours Truly) Nicki Minaj - 6.5 (Pink Friday and Pink Friday 2) Camila Cabello - 6.1 Romance Taylor Swift - 6.0 (Tortured Poets Anthology) Kesha - 5.9 (High Road) Beyoncé - 5.7 (I Am...Sasha Fierce) Lana - 5.5 (Born to Die) *P4k later corrected to 7.8 Halsey - 4.9 (Badlands) Rihanna - 4.5 (Unapologetic) Katy Perry - 4.5 (143) Madonna - 3.3 (I'm Going to Tell You a Secret) (4.5 for MDNA if only LPs) Miley Cyrus - 3.0 (Dead Petz) 2
BrattyBottom Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Dead Petz review makes me sad lol. I'm surprised at the 6.5 for Pink Friday 2. The original kind of deserves it but PF2 is like a 5 at best.
blown away Posted September 27 Posted September 27 27 minutes ago, Relampago. said: 4.5 for Unapologetic is just nasty Exactly. Now if it were one of the two mixtapes, fine. But not Unapologetic. 3
Kiss It Better Posted September 27 Posted September 27 56 minutes ago, Relampago. said: 4.5 for Unapologetic is just nasty the fact they did that just because she was back with chris brown is crazy 2 3
JoeAg Posted September 27 Posted September 27 need another rescore feature someday that'll give Unapologetic 7.8 at the LEAST y'all have already seen my opinions on that review either on here or on reddit lmao so i'll keep it cute but yeah, that one pisses me off to this day 1
Gelato Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Girls Aloud - WWTNS? (9.1) Olivia Rodrigo - SOUR (8.9) Jessie J - Who You Are (1.5) Pink - Trustfall (3.0) Mel C - Self-Titled (1.0) 1
glitch Posted September 27 Posted September 27 53 minutes ago, Gelato said: Girls Aloud - WWTNS? (9.1) OT: Tinashe 6.8 (Joyride)
Gelato Posted September 27 Posted September 27 (edited) 4 minutes ago, glitch said: OT: Tinashe 6.8 (Joyride) their lowest scored album being a 9.1 is so legendary truth be told the girls took some time to find their feet and i fear SOTU would've scored even lower (perhaps even an 8.9 ) if it wasn't for song of the decade You Freak Me Out OT: The Saturdays - Living for the Weekend (0.0) Edited September 27 by Gelato
blown away Posted September 27 Posted September 27 3 hours ago, Gelato said: Jessie J - Who You Are (1.5) This is not true, is it? I haven't listened to it in full yet, but I can't believe the album is that bad
FlyOnTheWall Posted September 27 Posted September 27 that dead petz rating says more about them than about the album. Losers omg
stevyy Posted September 27 Posted September 27 Mariah on Pitchfork: 9,0 - TEOM 7,9 - Daydream 7,7 - Me. I am Mariah 7,5 - Caution 7,3 - Merry Christmas (Anniversary) Pretty good.
Devin Posted September 27 Posted September 27 janet, billie, lana, and rihanna ones are disrespectful.
RoseBud Posted September 28 Posted September 28 On 9/27/2024 at 1:28 AM, NewStanner said: If this is real, I will never take Pitchfork seriously again Olivia only has two reviews GUTS is an 8.0 and SOUR was a 7.0
Recommended Posts