BlahBlahBlah Posted September 23 Posted September 23 If you look at their latest albums they aren't even comparable. Liberation is a well-written and honest effort (bar accelerate, I like it but it definitely is a mess) with good vocals. Sure, numbers were abysmal, but it has plenty of replay value and there's noticeable quality there. Out of Xtina's trinity Lotus is the only one that truly sucks. Katy... idk she served three solid duds in a row with a few bright moments here and there. 1
loveisdead9582 Posted September 23 Posted September 23 Bionic and lotus are better than the other four albums. For whatever reason, Katy still has label support and Christina's kind of disappeared after KGB 1
Terylee Posted September 23 Posted September 23 Bionic shouldn't be there. I know it was a flop back then, but it's actually an album I enjoy a lot.
prézli Posted September 23 Posted September 23 This song alone is better than Katy Perry's entire discography. Also, the Lotus Intro is LEGENDARY. 1 1
prézli Posted September 23 Posted September 23 57 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said: 143 had one charting song, unlike Liberation Liberation had songs nominated for Grammys. 1 1
leyaris11 Posted September 23 Posted September 23 Bigger flop: Xtina. Bionic is a mother of flop and the beginning downfall of a mpg.... And nobody top it ever since. Better flop: Katy Witness is not a flop, just underperformance, unlike Xtina and Katy mange to do a ww tour, chained to the rhythm, swish swish, bon Appetit are bops. Better artistry: had to give this to miss Xtina. Overall : Xtina, well she got to win somehow. 1
ChooseyLover Posted September 23 Posted September 23 I voted thinking bigger flop was positive Forgive me, Christina Maria Aguilera. 1
Trash Posted September 23 Posted September 23 Lotus is a terrible album that I overplayed when it came out, so I hate it. However none of Xtina's output could ever be as bad as Katy's Sure comercially Katy is on a bit of a better place than Xtina, but she also debuted 10 years later and during peak digital era. 143 might be the worst to the public perception and critics out of all these eras too. At least Xtina's last three efforts flopped in silence. 1
blueberries Posted September 23 Posted September 23 witness and smile had a moderate hit each so katy flopped the least but xtina's albums are far better
Erreur2 La Nature Posted September 23 Posted September 23 Katy clears but she's hated right now she's going to lose everything lol
Recommended Posts