base talk '143' Review Thread | MC: 37 (+2) | P4K: 4.5 | ATRL banner (OUT)

[CovalentBondage]

1 minute ago, AmericanIdol said:

Katy always wins in the end.

 

Y'all gonna hear her ROAR

[Famekillers]

2 minutes ago, AmericanIdol said:

Katy always wins in the end.

 

Y'all gonna hear her ROAR

The roar:

 

[katara]

17 minutes ago, TomTom said:

Fitting!

 

[A Million Lights]

People are doing too much on 143… what's the difference between this and brat?

[Nefertiti0]

Edited September 20 by Nefertiti0

[RideOrDie]

Just now, A Million Lights said:

People are doing too much on 143… what's the difference between this and brat?

DSGDHJHKFH i love this thread

 

[TomTom]

@Bends Metacritic updated!

38 

 

Edited September 20 by TomTom

[RideOrDie]

Just now, Nefertiti0 said:

it's 38 now, lower than vultures 2

 

[truthteller]

i'm on track 9 and not even a gay bathhouse would play such lifeless playlist

[Selegend]

38 is an INSANE score for real 

 

[Velvet]

38

 

[truthteller]

2 minutes ago, TomTom said:

@Bends Metacritic updated!

 

charlie puth get off the floor

Edited September 20 by truthteller

[Bends]

HDD released their prediction?

[Sugden]

debuted with 38 on metacritic (red)

 

Edited September 20 by Sugden

[katara]

2 minutes ago, A Million Lights said:

People are doing too much on 143… what's the difference between this and brat?

I mean yxou are not wrong 

[A Million Lights]

Just now, Bends said:

HDD released their prediction?

3.8k

[Selegend]

43 would be a cute score at this point

would match 143 title and would be yellow, not red. 

 

 

[Jude]

 

That American Idol come back is inevitable.

[Bends]

Metacritic

1 hour: 40 (peak, debut)

2 hour: 38 (-2, dropped by 5%) [

[Sannie]

7 minutes ago, Lady Claire said:

If NME and Variety panned then it's a terrible sign 😬

 

I was expecting around 45, but now i think it'll be 38? Kinda similar to In My Defense by Iggy

Makes sense she would score alongside one of her peers.  

[ontherocks]

14 minutes ago, thatsmydemi said:

 

 

 

 

Her team should never let her take any decision music-wise ever again. She's 100% lost it. So many wrong decisions in this era. It's just sad. 

There won't be a reason for her team to do anything at all in the future. I would be surprised if she even keeps her record deal after this. 

 

Edited September 20 by ontherocks

[Sugden]

[MonsterTown]

4 minutes ago, TomTom said:

@Bends Metacritic updated!

38 

 

OH NO

 

[BrokenMachine]

Me to all the red critics rn

 

[Bends]

Just now, Jude said:

 

That American Idol come back is inevitable.

That ***** said some nonsense that it was her worst job ever and she could have saved her 25M salary without leaving her chair.  Now she will get 5M at max.