base talk '143' Review Thread | MC: 37 (+2) | P4K: 4.5 | ATRL banner (OUT)

[Andraslop]

1 hour ago, Erotic said:

She could have rebounded after Witness so easily. She was happily pregnant, on national television every day, constant good press about her and Orlando. Instead she chose to double down on her cheesiness, outdated camp, and delivered a half-assed era with clown visuals thinking she was doing something. We blame and troll Witness for a lot, but that era actually had bops and SOME sort of substance. 
 

Her career really did die with a 

 

This!!! The album that killed her career is Smile, not Witness. She could have robounded after Witness, just as Gaga did after Artpop. But instead, she served the catastrophic and uneventful Smile era. That was the truly end.

[Relampago.]

This doesn't deserve higher than like.. 50. Full stop. No comma.mp4

[Nefertiti0]

6/10

 

[enchanted0]

5 minutes ago, Nefertiti0 said:

6/10

 

She WON. I'm so proud of her  

[GAGAISTHEBESTYA]

17 minutes ago, favorite crime said:

The 5/100 is fake. AOTY never gets any critic scores before they are posted on the critic's own page. Verified users can upload 'missing' critic scores. The fact that the link just leads to 143s AM page says all

So how come it's not any other publications but it has to be The A.V Club with that certain score  

[Kern]

10 minutes ago, Nefertiti0 said:

6/10

 

Oh Mike... you're always so nice. Maybe a little too nice!

 

 

[Nefertiti0]

5/10

 

[Peak Now]

Poptimism is back 

[Rino]

maybe it isn't that bad?
surprised critics are not tugging at her wig for hiring Puke though 

[Chemist]

1 hour ago, Squall said:

Why is the Sputnik one added?  

it's not if it says "waiting for approval" on the right

[Alaska.]

Wait @ the unexpected acclaim (for Katheryn's standards)

 

Let me do an outfit change real quick

 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

5/10 from Clash? Okayyyyy

Smile got a 2/10 for reference. 

[MonsterNavy]

1 hour ago, A Million Lights said:

The album isn't even bad, 5/100 sounds bitter 

 

1 hour ago, A Million Lights said:

Wow bitter gays downvoting my post, what a surprise i guess 

we're here to trash and hate on katy, if you want positivity go to the katy base

 

 

 

 

 

 

where is pitchfork? I never cared about reviews until now

 

 

[Nefertiti0]

2/5

 

[charot]

I don't **** with critics but always here for the mess

 

 

[Sugden]

2/5

 

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/katy-perry-review-143-tracklist-dr-luke-b2616096.html

 

 

[popmusicisdead]

Just now, Sugden said:

2/5

 

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/reviews/katy-perry-review-143-tracklist-dr-luke-b2616096.html

 

 

not the link serving Dr. Luke's Katy Perry 

[Peak Now]

P4K doesn't publish till like Monday I think

[Bends]

11 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

5/10 from Clash? Okayyyyy

Smile got a 2/10 for reference. 

2/10 has killed green MC zone for Smile.

[Bends]

Allmusic and Rolling Stone will give her 2.5 out 5. 

Edited September 20 by Bends

[Bends]

56 minutes ago, Nefertiti0 said:

6/10

 

Doesn't count.

 

[GAGAISTHEBESTYA]

Just now, Bends said:

Allmusic and Rolling Stone will gave her 2.5 out 5. 

so did it happen or will it happen 

[Bends]

Just now, GAGAISTHEBESTYA said:

so did it happen or will it happen 

It will happen, they won't rate her below 2. 

[Bends]

METACRITIC: 40 (COLD SHOT DEBUT)

https://www.metacritic.com/music/143/katy-perry

[Nicholai]

Painfully dated and glaringly out of touch