base talk Less impactful album of 2024: Eternal Sunshine Vs C,XOXO

[Migs]

34 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

This comparison would have made more sense

And most people would still vote for Camila

But that would be correct. RO had waaaaay more impact than C,XOXO, and that without featuring famous rappers  

[Reginald]

NOT Arianka's magnum opus being compared to #that album 

[Gabriel]

I know some of the Ariana songs, but none of the Camila. So I vote Camila. 

[magazine]

1 hour ago, Garbaj said:

how is eternal sunshine not impactful? tell me something i don't know.

a certain user would tell you ES was a huge flop and everybody hated the singles 

 

OT: It's camila, of course 

[Rihinvention]

I think I speak on behalf of a lot of non-US atrl members when I say I didn't even listen to C,XOXO. I skimmed through it for like 1-2 minutes to see if anything piqued my interest.

 

Wasn't even willing to give it a full 45 minute listen, or however long it is.

[TayDuaStan]

Eternal Sunshine at least had WCBF (which is a moderate hit). C,XOXO had nothing, just a string of flops and the album dropped like a rock on charts so… 

[TayDuaStan]

30 minutes ago, Migs said:

But that would be correct. RO had waaaaay more impact than C,XOXO, and that without featuring famous rappers  

Even Camila wanted her RO album cover moment with C,XOXO deluxe and she served the Dollar Store version of it 

 

[TipToe]

It's Cabello but lemme just say that i just learned in this thread that Ariana had 2 (two) #1's this year... The reception to her first singel was so mild that i thought she was kinda flopping in this aspect (i was aware the alberm sales are good tho)

[shyboi]

if we think about it, ES had less impact, CHOCHO made a lot of noise

[Daglazzo]

Lol how can you compare these… nobody listens to or cares about Camila. People may only know I luv it cause it's quite a noise that used to appear on tt back then. 

[YourFavoriteWeapon]

C,XOXO despite it being better

[DR0GO]

Please. 

[ImpressMeMuch]

3 hours ago, Badgalbriel said:

ES is harmless and it came and went, but at least people knew it existed for a week or two. 

it came and then ariana took it away and left (ended promo and focused on wicked)

 

 

[ImpressMeMuch]

2 hours ago, shyboi said:

if we think about it, ES had less impact, CHOCHO made a lot of noise

hate threads on atrl don't count as impact 

[bielneira]

Your attempt to drag Ariana failed miserably

[KKCuteCat]

3 hours ago, Nico Robin said:

Um are we being serious??

It was a troll obviously