base talk BLACKPINK's daughters: A better debut?

[illia]

BABYMONSTER - A new girlgroup under YG Entertainment, Blackpink's company

(people are divided whether Batter Up or Sheesh is their real debut so I included both)

 

 

MEOVV - A new girlgroup under THEBLACKLABEL, produced by Teddy (Blackpink's main producer)

 

 

Edited September 6 by illia

[Mattheo]

the khia off

[truthteller]

they be having three or four jingles and fizzle out like most girl groups after 3-4 years

[MonsterNavy]

  both are so bad

 

none of them are coming close to blackpink and i'm not even talking about success  

 

 

 

 

 

[BigBangStan]

Meovv but none come close to BP

[GucciBang]

Meovv easily, I also like the tones of their voices more

[illia]

For me: Sheesh > Meow > Batter Up

[elevate]

Meow is better than the other two; I genuinely found it hard to get through Sheesh and the baseball one. I also think Meovv has a better foundation in general; more cohesive with a clearer vibe & sound. That said, their next single has to be better or else they'll go the BM route. 

[Alaska.]

I see 2NELegends remain infertile

 

[rhaenyra]

As a Blink since pre debut and big YG fan, MEOVV had the better debut song and MV. It's really just facts

They really give me peak-BP vibes so idk why some "blinks" are mad...none of the Baemon songs fit BLACKPINK, but Meow sure does

&& idk about y'all, but the MEOVV members ate this up 

[Rev8]

Sheesh>Meovv>BU

 

but are pretty close (at least the last 2)

 

Meovv was too one and the same...while the other 2 at least have variety (and Sheesh is the only one to go back to imo)

idk... they are missing something..

[sweetkiss]

meovv

[WeFoundWill]

Meow is at least catchy and gets stuck in your head

[WeFoundWill]

55 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

  both are so bad

 

none of them are coming close to blackpink and i'm not even talking about success  

 

 

 

 

 

the collapse in 2016 when you clicked play on both of those right after each other  

[Comedor]

Another girl group?

 

Open the schools!

[Sheep]

2ne1 and their illegitimate daughters came out swinging with iconic debuts, these songs are not that. 

[Alena]

babymonster wins, meow was terrible

[kellebrity98]

babymonster songs are BAD, meovv ate that song up

[Pinkbutterflies]

O charisma. The visual looks like the girl from Apink before her plastic surgery.

[BOOMBAYAH]

I think after D4 BLACKPINK's music became super stale and practically soulless. What kept the group on top was the appeal of the individual members and the fact that no one else in the industry could match how endearing and cool they were. When you give this same stale musical formula to a group of girls who lack the identity and cool factor that the BLACKPINK members have, it just ends up being boring.

[Digitalism]

Meovv and it's not even close

It was always about Teddy

[GentleEarthquake]

Meovv

[willmcclure9]

Meovv but its a mid off

[toast]

Meovv suits the concept better

[supertiffany]

SHEESH>>>>
 

 

the rap alone

 

 

>>>>>>>