base talk What are Gaga's chances of Oscar nom after FAD mixed reception?

[narid]

JFAD has had a mixed reception in Venice, with critics noting that Gaga "has a completely blank facial expression" even during musical numbers.  

 

With her performance previously hyped as a Oscar frontrunner, this raises the question: What are Gaga's chances of a Oscar nom when the film and her performance have been reviewed as mid? Does she still have a shot?

[Human Fly]

why are u trying it? all of your latest posts are attacking gaga for no reason  

 

[Dom]

She was fantastic in HOG and did not get a nom. After these reviews I would say at best Globe nom and thats it.

[Vegvisir]

Get a job OP 

 

The only thing getting unanimous acclaim about J:FAD is Gaga's performance.

Joaquin nabbed his first lead Oscar for Joker even though it had a similar critic response.

 

She literally just got a 12 min standing ovation for her role.

[A-V-XYZ]

Joaquin won an Oscar even though the reviews for The Joker were mixed. Same could happen for Gaga.

[narid]

6 minutes ago, Vegvisir said:

She literally just got a 12 min standing ovation for her role.

Everyone does babe. Almodovár* had 18 minutes. 

 

Edited September 4 by narid

[Doctor Dick]

I would love for her to get a nom but even when she doesn't it will only make her work even harder which ultimately will give her both a nom and a win and cause you and your fellow haters to meltdown 

[Vegvisir]

Just now, narid said:

Everyone does babe. Almodover had 18 minutes. 

Almodóvar*, and yeah... what about it? He's an accomplished filmmaker with 2 Oscars.

[Smarticle]

She's not getting a nom, you're right ATRL user narid. You can smile and live happily now without fuming over her every move 

[RideOrDie]

 

 

[Dom]

1 minute ago, Smarticle said:

She's not getting a nom, you're right ATRL user narid. You can smile and live happily now without fuming over her every move 

At least she is being praised left right for her performance and she already has a nomination, so at the end of the day only way is UP.

[narid]

1 minute ago, Vegvisir said:

Almodóvar*, and yeah... what about it? He's an accomplished filmmaker with 2 Oscars.

Thanks for correcting my typo. 

[Loca]

It's still possible, given the weakness of this race. It will all depend on the box office and the industry's reception, just like it did for the previous film. 

[Antisocialites]

I think she only has chances in the supporting category.

[shyboi]

The praise alone should grant her a nom, I remember the reception for Blonde was terrible and Ana still got the nom 

 

 

AWARDS SEASON 2025 IS OURS

 

[narid]

5 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

 

 

Hopefully the Academy will agree with these critics. 

[єѕℓαм]

Oh you're so pressed at Gaga's 12 min standing ovation i see 

[kexin]

0

[rickycabello123]

i saw the premiere press conference, there will be a song or two they sing together.. what the song called? why no one talk about it, give us tea about the music at the movie chile

Edited September 4 by rickycabello123

[MonsterTown]

29 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

 

 

they can't hide gaga got the praise again...in multiple reviews....

[alfonso12]

Her performance has been universally acclaimed and:

 

1 hour ago, A-V-XYZ said:

Joaquin won an Oscar even though the reviews for The Joker were mixed. Same could happen for Gaga.

this.

[bielneira]

Who knows...

[Archetype]

1 hour ago, shyboi said:

I remember the reception for Blonde was terrible and Ana still got the nom 

Omg I completely forgot about that 

 

Yea it doesn't really matter how good or bad the film is at this point, she bodied her role based on the reviews.  GP reception and box office numbers will probably determine if she gets a nom or not.

[UnusualBoy]

I think she'll get the nom, will she win? We'll have to see who is she against with...

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

Did she ever have chances