poll Maneater vs. Promiscuous vs. Say It Right

[A Million Lights]

Edited September 4 by A Million Lights

[Goaty]

Say It Right for both. All three are amazing songs though

[itshyolee]

All three songs are amazing, but Say It Right low key clears

[Teen Spirit]

Maneater is one of the best songs of the 00s.

[Hector]

Maneater but Promiscuous most iconic after the recent TikTok revival in the last few years. 

[Johnny Jacobs]

Say it right. End thread. The first ten seconds alone chile 

[BeenTheShit]

Love all of them, but Say It Right is leagues above the other two.

[Gladiator]

I voted for Say It Right for best song and Promiscuous for more iconic.

[Sugar-Rush]

Slay It Right > Promiscuous > Maneater

[bielneira]

1. "Say It Right"

2. "Promiscuous"

[Homebrand]

I know atrl loves to overrate the hell out of say it right but promiscuous is the better song. The back and forth between Tim and Nelly, original and timeless production (arguably Timbaland's best), serving sex.

 

It definitely deserved it's success and recurrent streams 

[rebeltwat]

For the longest time I would've said Promiscuous but lately I've been feeling Maneater soooo hard. Finally we're waking up to Say It Right being overrated. 

[YourFavoriteWeapon]

If I had to rank them it would be Promiscuous > Say It Right > Maneater though I love all of them equally. Loose is such a fantastic album front to back and deserves the retrospective acclaim it's been receiving over the last couple years. 

[vince_martin88]

Will forever be salty at how poorly her team handled Maneater as a single in the US. Would've been her 3rd #1.

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

3 minutes ago, vince_martin88 said:

Will forever be salty at how poorly her team handled Maneater as a single in the US. Would've been her 3rd #1.

Same here. Remember following its chart run and how it suddenly collapsed. 

[Scandalous]

maneater is my fav i think, but the least iconic. say it right is probably the most remembered one

[vince_martin88]

4 minutes ago, OnlyManInTheWorld said:

Same here. Remember following its chart run and how it suddenly collapsed. 

iirc, they released it as Promiscuous was at its peak right?

[trueromance]

these are all classics honestly but i went with Slay it Right for both

[bjorn]

1 hour ago, vince_martin88 said:

Will forever be salty at how poorly her team handled Maneater as a single in the US. Would've been her 3rd #1.

What happened? 
 

Shocked to find out it peaked at #16 in the US when it was a smash in Europe, following Promiscuous #1. Then Say it Right going #1 after. Wth…

 

 

[vince_martin88]

1 hour ago, bjorn said:

What happened? 
 

Shocked to find out it peaked at #16 in the US when it was a smash in Europe, following Promiscuous #1. Then Say it Right going #1 after. Wth…

 

 

I think it was either given a limited release in the US or it was release during Promiscuous' peak which overshadowed it.

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

3 hours ago, vince_martin88 said:

iirc, they released it as Promiscuous was at its peak right?

 

2 hours ago, bjorn said:

What happened? 
 

Shocked to find out it peaked at #16 in the US when it was a smash in Europe, following Promiscuous #1. Then Say it Right going #1 after. Wth…

 

 

 

1 hour ago, vince_martin88 said:

I think it was either given a limited release in the US or it was release during Promiscuous' peak which overshadowed it.

They pulled it out of the radio to make room for Say It Right  

[Maneater]

I will never stan another song the way I stanned Maneater

[Alldeezy]

All those 3 are AMAZING to me during high school days I STANNED them all

it's hard to choose between Maneater and Say It Right    but maneater the album version because the last minute of that extended version with Timbaland probably wins the 3 for me. 

[JoAddams]

All Good Things

 

but Maneater was always that girl 

[TipToe]

Say It Right better sing, Promiscuous more iconic. I never cared much about Maneater for some reason.