poll Valerie vs. Die with a Smile: Better?

[Lagerfeld]

Both songs have a strong retro vibe, especially with Valerie's Motown-inspired arrangement. Similarly, both Bruno Mars and Lady Gaga are known for incorporating vintage styles into their music. Which song is better?

 

 

Edited September 2 by Lagerfeld

[shookspeare]

The snort I let out chile

[playboi]

Valerie was made at the peak of Amy's artistry

 

Die was made to pay off bruno's debts

[jdanton2]

both are good but i will go with Die With A Smile . by the way Bruno did a cover of the song as part of a Amy tribute several years ago.

 

 

Edited September 2 by jdanton2

[Devin]

love valerie but ima go with dwas.

[Shimenawa]

Valerie is nice but it's a cover, not an original song so the comparison is a bit random

 

Edited September 2 by Shimenawa

[Lightbringer007]

31 minutes ago, jdanton2 said:

both are good but i will go with Die With A Smile . by the way Bruno did a cover of the song as part of a Amy tribute several years ago.

 

 

this is absolutely incredible!

[Green]

I like both but Valerie by far

[Rino]

you know Bruno and Gaga cooked up a classic when OGHs put it against thee Valerie 

[aesthetic bih]

Amy. Also let the legend rest in peace. This comparison is disrespectful.

[JoeAg]

I hate to make it look like recency bias is getting the best of me but Valerie has genuinely always been so overrated lol

 

Valerie is nice, and Amy made it her OWN, just like she did with most of her fantastic covers! but when it's stacked up against a discography containing You Sent Me Flying / Cherry, Know You Now, I Heard Love Is Blind, In My Bed, Take the Box, Amy Amy Amy, You Know I'm No Good, Me and Mr. Jones, Back to Black, Love Is a Losing Game, Wake Up Alone, and He Can Only Hold Her… well… yeah. it's not nearly as remarkable as any of those songs tbh 

 

Amy's my queen, her legacy remains FOREVER, and as a fellow jewish singer I look up to her endlessly

 

for me, Die with a Smile is the better song

[wish]

Let's not do this 

[Blue Monday]

Valerie is in a whole other league let's just say that

 

[Summerboy95]

Why are these being compared?

[awong918]

Well, I would only listen to 1 of the 2 and it's not the Valerie cover. I do like the original, however.

 

Edited September 2 by awong918

[Ethereaaal]

The fact that this comparison came sooner than DWAS vs Shallow. So random. 

[EnigmaticAndroid]

Weird comparison, but Valerie is an all-timer for me 

[James_Dean]

I can't believe this is even a question 

 

[Human Fly]

I like both 

[RihannaRTT]

a 25/10 vs an 8/10.

 

[CherryBay]

Valerie was classic on arrival so this