base talk Short n' Sweet vs GUTS

[YellowRibbon]

Taste vs All American *****

PPP vs Bad Idea Right?

Good Graces vs Vampire 

Sharpest Tool vs Lacy 

Coincidence vs Ballad of a Homeschooled Girl

Bed Chem vs Making the Bed 

Espresso vs Logical 

Dumb & Poetic vs Get Him Back! 

Slim Pickins vs Love Is Embarrassing 

Juno vs The Grudge 

Lie to Girls vs Pretty Isn't Pretty

Don't Smile vs Teenage Dream

 

As I said, S&S clears

[Maxxxine]

SNS is fun, listenable, pop perfection. 

Guts is loud, bananees and avocadees cursive singing which I can't stand, throw that one out. 

[Lasso]

be serious.

 

Taste vs All American *****

PPP vs Bad Idea Right? (i love p³ though)

Good Graces vs Vampire 

Sharpest Tool vs Lacy 

Coincidence vs Ballad of a Homeschooled Girl

Bed Chem vs Making the Bed 

Espresso vs Logical [NEITHER]

Dumb & Poetic vs Get Him Back! 

Slim Pickins vs Love Is Embarrassing 

Juno vs The Grudge [NEITHER]

Lie to Girls vs Pretty Isn't Pretty

Don't Smile vs Teenage Dream

[yonsé]

sabrina won this round.

 

SOUR > emails i should never send

 

GOD N SWEET > guts

[liquiddiamonds]

GUTS had something to say about growing up and major personality with its sound 

 

It will take Sabrina more albums to catch up with Olivia. Liv is simply the better writer with the better vision 

[Lachlan]

Short n Sweet is very subpar. 

[RoseBud]

   I love Sabrina but GUTS is on another level.

[Brooklyn Baby]

GUTS sweetie… although I do like SNS

[Avenue]

Guts as an album is miles better.

 

Short n sweet has too much saccharine pop fillers that are way below the level of its singles but the massive singles of Short n Sweet bop harder than guts.

 

Lacy >>>>>> all tracks on either albums

[Ego.]

Guts is such a well made album in all regards. SNS is good but it definitely lacks the depth of guts and its noticeable when listening to the entire album, though there are some amazing tracks in there

[saintspice]

Both have like 7 excellent tracks and then the rest is just okay to me.  Not bad by any means but wont return to them unless I'm doing a full album listen. Taste has me gagged right now so I voted for shortie but they're pretty equal to me as I've had my moment with many songs on guts as well. 

[honestopinion]

I still listen to Guts every single day and never get tired of it. Short N sweet was cute yesterday but I don't have any desire to listen to it today. I love that Olivia's album has more depth and different topics and amazingly produced

[KillingYourCareer]

GUTS has personality and Olivia sounds like a human singing. Also, it's Jack Antonoff-free.

[cuteboyzay]

Short N' Sweet is just SO GOOD I'm sorry. Just bop after bop after bop and I prefer the lyricism a little more just because I'm a horny b*tch. Not only that but she really served something sooooo refreshing and the versatility is through the roof. You can tell Sabrina has an amazingggg ear for hits.

 

GUTS is great but I preferred SOUR a little more. It felt fresh and new, and GUTS just sounds like what we've already heard from Olivia. Regardless,  both great albums but Short N' Sweet Just DOES IT for me. 

[Acuminatus]

It's kinda like GUTS vs SOUR in that the big hits are more catchy in SOUR but the album GUTS overall is higher quality 

 

GUTS > S&S > SOUR

[NorbertMinaj]

Why can't these two albums be appreciated for what they are?

Some of you guys are weird (and not in a Republican way) 😉😛

[Heldenzeit]

Guts is miles ahead Shart & ****

Edited August 24 by Heldenzeit

[Nico Robin]

Taste vs All American *****

PPP  vs Bad Idea Right?

Good Graces vs Vampire 

Sharpest Tool vs Lacy 

Coincidence vs Ballad of a Homeschooled Girl

Bed Chem vs Making the Bed 

Espresso vs Logical 

Dumb & Poetic vs Get Him Back! 

Slim Pickins vs Love Is Embarrassing 

Juno vs The Grudge 

Lie to Girls vs Pretty Isn't Pretty

Don't Smile vs Teenage Dream

 

2/10

 

GUTS easily takes this

Edited August 24 by Nico Robin

[fever2288]

The one with ww smashes (another one incoming) 

[thatsmydemi]

1. All American ***** vs Taste

2. Bad Idea Right? vs Please Please Please

3. Vampire vs Good Graces

4. Lacy vs Sharpest Tool

5. Ballad Of A Homeschooled Girl vs Coincidence

6. Making The Bed vs Bed Chem

7. Logical vs Espresso

8. Get Him Back! vs Dumb And Poetic

9. Love Is Embarrassing vs Slim Pickins

10. The Grudge vs Juno

11. Pretty Isn't Pretty vs Lie To Girls

12. Teenage Dream vs Don't Smile

 

 

I liked SNS but GUTS is on another league

[Daglazzo]

Logical and vampire annihilate all 6 albums of Sabrina 

[lovely88]

I don't think either album is that great. But I'll go with Short n Sweet for this round. Guts felt like a Sour retread, even the aesthetics were barely different. I have a feeling that it won't be highly regarded as Olivia's best work. Whereas Short n Sweet actually feels like an evolution from Emails plus it does have more stand out singles.

Edited August 24 by lovely88