base talk Born This Way vs Warrior

[Josh]

[Rihinvention]

Born This Way has higher highs, but lower lows. I respect the risk though. Warrior feels like it has a lot of generic, forgotten filler.

 

However I feel like Kesha chose the right singles, but Gaga didn't. But even with the "wrong" singles, Gaga still had the better singles.

 

Gonna have to give both to Born This Way.

[GraceRandolph]

Born This Way for sure. 

[bielneira]

1. Born This Way

2. Born This Way

[Sheep]

One of the greatest pop albums of all time vs Kesha's worst. Hasn't she been through enough why are we doing set up threads?

Edited August 20 by Sheep

[babyforlife]

lol

[TaylorsSquad]

I prefer Warrior because I'm attached to it and it sucks that a shooting stopped Die Young's momentum. 

[Bussea]

Warrior tbh. I always thought BTW was overrated. But it's singles > Warrior's

[NEUTRON]

Gaga delivered. Kesha didn't. 

[ChooseyLover]

The tea is that Warrior is the better album and Born This Way had the better singles but are we ready for this conversation?

Edited August 20 by ChooseyLover

[sunbathinganimal]

[LustSpell]

A joke of a thread. Born This Way by far.

[KillingYourCareer]

Warrior has several excellent songs (Thinking of You, Only Wanna Dance with You, Love Into the Light...), but Born This Way only has a couple I don't use, it's better.

[Heldenzeit]

Marry The Night / Warrior

Born This Way / Die Young

Government Hooker / C'Mon

Judas / Thinking Of You

Americano / Crazy Kids

Hair / Wherever You Are

Scheiße / Dirty Love (feat. Iggy Pop)

Bloody Mary / Wonderland

Bad Kids / Only Wanna Dance With You

Highway Unicorn (Road To Love) / Supernatural

Heavy Metal Lover /  All That Matters (The Beautiful Life)

Electric Chapel / Love Into The Light

You and I / Last Goodbye

The Edge Of Glory / Gold Trans Am

Black Jesus + Amen Fashion / Out Alive

Fashion Of His Love / Past Lives

The Queen / Old Flames Can't Hold a Candle To You

 

 

Born This Way: 9

Warrior: 8

 

[The7thStranger]

Both only have a few decent songs on them.

 

Warrior has an excuse for being as bad as it is, that being Dr. Luke's control over the project and Kesha not being able to carry the album to completion as she had envisioned it. These days, I only use C'mon.

 

GaGa put a lot of effort into Born This Way and had more creative control, so it does contain some interesting experimentation. But the production has aged very poorly, and I don't think the songwriting is all that good. I don't own this album, but I remember liking Bloody Mary (shame about TikTok ruining it), Judas, and Heavy Metal Lover.

 

TBH, it's a tie in terms of enjoying listening experience, but BTW gets points for actually representing the artist who made it.

 

 

[Kimi]

one is a pop classic the other is terrible generic pop album yall are unserious