live performance Idina Menzel hits strained flat note, tries again and again and again

[SoldierofLove]

 

5:10

 

Clip of her challenging the audience to sing it better and they do!

https://www.instagram.com/reel/C-RxG9PufJL/?utm_source=ig_web_button_share_sheet

 

 

ATRL gays, do you think you could sing it better? 

[Buffy]

She should lower the pitch….

[Reginald]

I'm SCREAMING  it's good that she has a sense of humor about it 

 

[Joey307]

"Because I screwed up the lyric" 

[Hair]

Omfg how embarrassing I can't, the last 30 seconds she was ready for a meltdown

[Adam’s Eve]

Serving

 

 

[Joey307]

1 minute ago, Adam's Eve said:

Serving

 

 

Oh don't be harsh, Meghan got better as she got older 

[Cheers]

Literally screaming into the mic. I cannot!

 

[Adam’s Eve]

1 minute ago, Joey307 said:

Oh don't be harsh, Meghan got better as she got older 

Meghan, as in Trainor?

[Jotham]

I had the video playing in another tab and I flinched when she went "OOOOON" again at 6:40

Edited August 14 by Jotham

[Kayseri Mantisi]

but she's a beast baby so it doesn't matter 

 

 

[Loca]

@Kukai what are your thoughts, if you don't mind me asking?

[Mikeymoonshine]

She's hilarious looks like her vocal chords just said "no not tonight". It's difficult to hit notes like that all the time even for a great singer. 

[DevilsRollTheDice]

She has butchered this live so many times, I don't understand why she doesn't take it down a couple of semitones. 

[Walk_Away21]

Shrieking

[Curaga]

I would be surprised if I saw an artist retry only a part of a song like that (and so many times too  ). I feel like it would have been more professional to accept the 1st flat note and move on, but maybe this is what her audience expects/enjoys/relates to?

 

Edited August 14 by Curaga

[Simple]

Noise pollution at the end, I would sue her 

[shookspeare]

wow adele dazeem fell off

[JohnCrawford]

she used to screw up hight notes even in 2004. Her technique is terrible

[Delirious]

i love her 10000% more after this lol

[Funhouse]

Why does she keep doing this to herself 

 

[popmusicisdead]

she sounded terrible even on the record. idk what y'all were expecting 

[ultraviolence.xx]

48 minutes ago, Buffy said:

She should lower the pitch….

23 minutes ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:

She has butchered this live so many times, I don't understand why she doesn't take it down a couple of semitones. 

she already has  it's lower than the studio version

[Yes, AND]

She should just lip that one note. 

[glitch]

I don't understand why she always sings like that. Making that short "a" sound is rarely going to come out well. She should try a longer "a" like the one in car or an "oh" sound so it doesn't sound as harsh.