poll Erotica vs Justify My Love vs Human Nature

[ariesgroove]

 

 

 

which one is ur fav? 

 

Edited August 13 by ariesgroove

[Loca]

Human Nature clearly the weakest here. My favorite of the other two depends on my mood, generally favoring Justify My Love.

Edited August 13 by Loca

[Abracadabra]

All are a serve but Human Nature wins for me

[Nightingale]

Human Nature has a great theme rarely explored in pop music but I just don't find it that catchy.
 

Erotica is #1 for me out of these followed by Justify My Love

[RideOrDie]

erotiqué 

[Venice B]

I'd go with Erotica 

[Breakdown]

It's very, very close, but I'll go with Erotica. Justify My Love is is incredible though. Human Nature is the clear #3 in this comparison though.

[James_Dean]

Erotica

[pisuke]

Erotica

Human Nature

Justify My Love

 

All three 10000000000000000/10 btw. 

[BGKC]

Erotica > Justify > Human
 

All 3 are immaculate tho. 

[The7thStranger]

Human Nature > Erotica >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Justify My Love

[UseYourIllusion2002]

Justify My Love for video and Erotica for song. I'm not the biggest fan of Human Nature tbh. It's a good song but I absolutely love the other two songs. 

[Charmed Life]

Erotica

Justify

Human Nature

[LikeaRebel]

Erotica > Human Nature > JML

[SlowGinFizzzz]

(Erotica/You Thrill Me from the Confessions Tour) > Justify My Love > Erotica > Human Nature 

[Mitsouko]

Erotica is my favorite song and video from all three but they're all 10/10

[LOTF]

Hmm, I just can't choose

[Kimi]

Justify My love should be on Erotica, it would be the best song there 

Edited August 14 by Kimi

[KLatz]

All are sooo good, but Human Nature is one of my absolute favorite Madonna tracks. Plus, that video!

[potent]

All great, Erotica kinda clears though

[YourHonesty]

Gagged by the fact that one discography contains all three of these mind-blowing songs but that's why Madonna will always be the queen.

 

HN, while iconic, is a notch below the others. JML and Erotica are honestly a coin flip, but while I prefer the former's music video, the latter gave us some of her best remixes (check out the William Orbit 12" mix and the Underground Club mix, you're welcome).

 

Erotica takes it on the strength of its unsung older cousin, You Thrill Me.

[TipToe]

I looove Erotica, the dirty/underground-ish sound is so exquisite... I remember watching its video in the good ole days of MTV when i was only a child and being literally in a trance. I haven't got a clue about what it was all about but it somehow really pleased my senses and still do.

[Dark Miracles]

Human Nature

Justify My Love

Erotica

[rebeltwat]

They're already in order

[bleuwaffle]

Justify My Love, easily. It's a truly revolutionary, artful moment in pop music history. The Beast Within mix is beautiful too.