alexrex Posted August 5 Posted August 5 I mean, he has several hits under his belt. The latest is Please, Please Please by Sabrina Carpenter. And also he is responsible for most of Taylor's latest records, which have been highly succesful. Is he the best pop producer of all time? 1 15 3 2
Mephisto Posted August 5 Posted August 5 Every other producer >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> will.i.am >>> jack antonoff 3 1 6 1 4
KFC Posted August 5 Posted August 5 Did he produce What Was I Made For? If so then yes, if not then no 1
Illuminati Posted August 5 Posted August 5 Depends on the criteria, best song of all time was not produced by either but Jack is still not as omnipresent as Max Martin, so in a way Max Martin is the best producer of all time
cuteboyzay Posted August 5 Posted August 5 (edited) If the only people you can bring up are Sabrina and Taylor as "good examples". Then girl he def isn't the best. Not only that but I feel Taylor would be nearly just as successful even if Jack wasn't her main go-to lmao! Buuttt he is one of the finest and I'd let that man do so many things to me omfggg!!! Edited August 5 by cuteboyzay
Klein Posted August 5 Posted August 5 3 minutes ago, cuteboyzay said: If the only people you can bring up are Sabrina and Taylor as "good examples". Then girl he def isn't the best. Not only that but I feel Taylor would be nearly just as successful even if Jack wasn't her main go-to lmao! Buuttt he is one of the finest and I'd let that man do so many things to me omfggg!!! Well he also worked with Lorde and Lana, his band with Fun and then The Bleachers, etc… he's a very polyvalent producer that can really adapt to what the artist wants/needs. that said, he is not the best of all time. A great one yes but that's it. 2
Archie Posted August 5 Posted August 5 (edited) OTH will try and say that he is mediocre and a loser but he's given us many incredible moments that I would consider highlights in people's discography's. - All of NFR but notably the Venice ***** - All of Melodrama but notably the breakdown in Hard Feelings. - Brilliant moments in Masseduction - Amoeba by Clairo - Folklore Like sure, he has production tactics he repeats a lot and he's probably overworked, but he is a brilliant man. He's not the best of all time but he is definitely a good producer. Edited August 5 by Archie 1
loveisdead9582 Posted August 5 Posted August 5 No. Not even top 5/10. He's out out some decent work but no where near the best.
suburbannature Posted August 5 Posted August 5 31 minutes ago, Archie said: OTH will try and say that he is mediocre and a loser but he's given us many incredible moments that I would consider highlights in people's discography's. - All of NFR but notably the Venice ***** - All of Melodrama but notably the breakdown in Hard Feelings. - Brilliant moments in Masseduction - Amoeba by Clairo - Folklore Like sure, he has production tactics he repeats a lot and he's probably overworked, but he is a brilliant man. He's not the best of all time but he is definitely a good producer. All that just to say no 5 1
Recommended Posts