poll Will GaGa's new album be more successful than Brat?

[Ramcoro]

21 minutes ago, Jay07 said:

Gaga has a bigger dedicated fanbase so it will debut bigger. After that, we have to see if something catches on.

This. 

 

--

Although BRAT surprised me, so maybe Gaga will too!

[Happylittlepunk]

There is potential there but Gaga will need to actually promote and make things interesting. But I feel as a fan Gaga is past a point where she shouldn't care about charting anymore and focus on more delivering high quality music and acclaim instead.

[By the Water]

That's a very low bar and yet I can't say it will for sure 

[John Slayne]

[Paultea]

It's hard to use brat as a comparison because they are coming from 2 different places in their careers. 
 

What does worry me is the out of place ageism that is everywhere online now that has specifically been targeting artists in their mid 30s-40s. I think that could throw off an era because it doesn't even matter if the songs are good or not, there will always be jokes/comments about them being too old now. And they oddly come from a lot of people their same age. Gaga doing acting helps with this, but I'm already preparing to see a lot of those comments and wonder if it will hinder longevity. 

[TayDuaStan]

Comparing Charli XBOX to Lady freaking Gaga… Ok… enough internet for today 

[Dancehall Queen]

Probably not. Brat is a phenomenon. 

[yonsé]

1 hour ago, Kukai said:

Lady GaGa and Charli XCX have the same target demographic.

Do they?

[ericcartman]

Bigger debut and maybe second week, then drop as fast as Chromatica while Brat is still top20

[alexrex]

5 minutes ago, yonsé said:

Do they?

Yuh, the popper gays 

[on the line]

I'd hope so. Brat isn't doing that well on the charts. It's popularity is centered on memes, not the music. 

[Nazareth]

Depends on how the songs are received and if the promotion for the album is good.
 

I recon it will do more units overall than Brat, it's Lady Gaga after all. She'll be doing another stadium tour, so the album will probably perform around the same level as Chromatica or maybe even better. 

[hugoflegend]

Depends on how you define success. Charli last two albums hit #3 and #7 on the Billboard 200, and Gaga's last two albums both went #1. Gaga's numbers have a good chance of being better. For cultural impact it is more up in the air, Gaga could reach those heights, but it's up to how much effort she decides to put into it. Sooo, who knows? 

[єѕℓαм]

She's gonna have a way bigger debut that's for sure after that we'll have to wait and see but i'll definitely be enjoying Gaga's album more 

I couldn't get into Charli's album at all tbfh 

[Iceland]

GaGa will have a "good luck baby" sized hit

[Loca]

LG7 will be bigger and better than TTPD

[prézli]

She will be 40 when that album will be released.

 

[Chainsmoker]

6 hours ago, Miss Americana said:

Isn't Brat already on track to spend more weeks in the top 10 than any gaga album since TFM?

BTW spent 4 weeks in the top 10 after debuting with 1M* so it's a NO unless she surprises us all by miraculously releasing her second most successful album.

Wait I didn't know it was that frontloaded

 

OT-No

[lg6chromatica]

It'll probably have a bigger first week. Idk longevity-wise. But regardless, Lady Gaga has nothing left to prove, and if we're being petty, her peak was literally 1000x greater than anything Charli XCX has or will ever experience in her entire career.

[lg6chromatica]

8 hours ago, Cheers said:

Only for the first week. Then it's going to be competing with Katy's 143.

Please be serious. Chromatica spent 41 weeks on the Hot 200. Katy's last album spent 4 

[cyberraga]

8 hours ago, drip drop said:

brat > ttpd > GaGa's new album > 143

Brat is not more successful than TTPD be serious

 

anyway this thread is a poor attempt at trolling 

[cyberraga]

8 hours ago, Gorjesspazze9 said:

Did her last album? 

Chromatica was at double the units of Brat in the US at this point (2 months post release)

[Sad Beautiful Tragic]

 No, I'm afraid the gay community tends to be extremely fickle and has chosen Charli XCX as their representative pop girl for the foreseeable future. Gaga is heading towards a Woman's World trajectory, if anything.

 

[mrpartyrocker]

10 hours ago, Miss Americana said:

Isn't Brat already on track to spend more weeks in the top 10 than any gaga album since TFM?

BTW spent 4 weeks in the top 10 after debuting with 1M* so it's a NO unless she surprises us all by miraculously releasing her second most successful album.

not you comparing the album sales in 2024 with 2010  pls don't tell me you think brat is or will be bigger than tfm 

[MadMax12]

Depends on the music. Today, all the songs on the charts are loud and punchy. Chromatica was too compressed and watered down, but it sounds like she has a better producer with LG7 who will go all out