KatyPrismSpirit Posted August 3 Posted August 3 1 minute ago, Squall said: I mean, you stan Woman's World, be serious i mean you asked the question and I basically answered katy isn't the topic. Carly's last few albums have all received pretty lackluster acclaim. Nowhere near the level of BRAT, Pop 2, Charli self-titled. Dedicated was a dud, The Loneliest Time was low key all over the place. The Loveliest time had some cute moments but nobody knows about that record.
Squall Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 (edited) 1 minute ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: i mean you asked the question and I basically answered katy isn't the topic. Carly's last few albums have all received pretty lackluster acclaim. Nowhere near the level of BRAT, Pop 2, Charli self-titled. Dedicated was a dud, The Loneliest Time was low key all over the place. The Loveliest time had some cute moments but nobody knows about that record. My point is you shouldn't be the one talking about « mid music » when you stan one of the worst songs of 2024. If anything, it's actually a great indicator that you don't like Carly's music. Edited August 3 by Squall
Billionaire Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Between being on the Barbie soundtrack & BRAT's promotion prior to release I think Charli & her label are just better at getting her name out there. Also yes Charli is generally seen as the 'cooler' artist
magazine Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Just now, Squall said: And I corrected it immediately, it's not like it was intentional imagine being so mad someone called you unfunny that all you have left is… a 30 second typo in a thread title on an online forum Neither my post was a joke, and yet you were quick to claim it and quote me 5 times like a weirdo It's just a comment "on an online forum", why are you so mad? Break a leg or something. Jesus
Squall Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 1 minute ago, zuzufruit said: because charli consistently serves incredible, quality music while carly has released like 3 good songs in her career Fun fact: Crash and The Loneliest Time have the same Metacritic score
Squall Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 1 minute ago, magazine said: Neither my post was a joke, and yet you were quick to claim it and quote me 5 times like a weirdo It's just a comment "on an online forum", why are you so mad? Break a leg or something. Jesus People quoting you because you… quote them are acting weird? Damn, you really need help
applestar Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Charli, a success? she can't eclipse the iggy azalea song 1
Orsay Posted August 3 Posted August 3 (edited) Charli makes more inventive, boundary pushing music and understands how to curate a "cool factor" with the kids much better than Carly. Probably helps that she's 7 years younger on that front Not the downvote I like Carly and she makes great pop music, but her stuff and her sound could have easily come out prior to the EDM wave of the early 2010s. Charli's sound on the other hand is very clearly post-EDM craze and a product of how people were trying to make dance pop interesting again when the GP had tired of the endless repetitive drops. Some of y'all may look down your noses at hyperpop, but it is a fresher and more innovative genre than what Carly does, plain and simple. And it's a big part of Charlis current cultural cachet Edited August 3 by Orsay 2 2
magazine Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Just now, Squall said: People quoting you because you… quote them are acting weird? Damn, you really need help See, now I know you're trolling because you were the first to quote me with some nonsense. Speaking of help, like the one you needed to write the title You should be grateful me and the gurls are bumping this thread and giving you a smash. 1
katysuxx Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Carly Rae Jepson had bad luck with management and label presenting her as this empty headed pop singer! 'I Really like you' MV starring Justin Bieber is one of the clear examples. 1
Dragonfly Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Carly blessed the world with one of the best albums of all time, i.e. Daddycated, but people would rather remain tasteless it seems 1
glitch Posted August 3 Posted August 3 4 minutes ago, Cesar said: Charli is an ARTIST, Carly is not I'm kinda thinking some of you don't really listen to her music if you're making statements like this. Carly has the magic touch when it comes to writing a catchy pop hook, in the way even a lot of big label writing camps don't have. She basically condensed a whole musical into the length of a pop song You don't have to like the music she makes but to imply she's not creative or artistic is simply not true 4 1
Escape Posted August 3 Posted August 3 28 minutes ago, magazine said: Sis, you couldn't even make the title of your own thread make sense The self-drag Girl please, the title is perfectly understandable...
The7thStranger Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Carly is an artist from a by-gone era. She would have been really popular had she debuted in the mid-1980s.
Squall Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 Just now, Kanes said: Girl please, the title is perfectly understandable... I accidentally typed « doesn't » twice, corrected myself and he was obsessed over it for some reason, don't mind him 1
magazine Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Just now, Kanes said: Girl please, the title is perfectly understandable... The edited title?
Escape Posted August 3 Posted August 3 (edited) 3 minutes ago, Squall said: I accidentally typed « doesn't » twice, corrected myself and he was obsessed over it for some reason, don't mind him Yeah, anyone can tell it was unintentional and knows exactly what the title meant. Doing the most. Edited August 3 by Kanes
Taylor fanboy Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Obviously poor marketing. We all saw EMOTION under Scooter's wings. 1
taemin Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Carly's musical output has been declining ever since emotion side b imo. Charli is still trying new things while Carly is just doing the same thing she's been doing for almost a decade now.
shookspeare Posted August 3 Posted August 3 For as much as gays gas up Emotion, Carly's streams are very underwhelming. atrl hype not translating into streams I fear, a normani tea
Recommended Posts