mxoonlight Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Demi has better pop songs but I think holistically Miley's catalog is a bit more interesting. 1 1
Selegend Posted August 2 Posted August 2 (edited) Hard to tell. From a personal point of view: I like Miley more than i like Demi and Miley highs are wayy higher (she has some classicssss) but she also does have the worst consistancy among ex acts. Like, u never know if u're going to listen to the best song u have ever heard or the worst song u have ever heard when it comes to Miley. This is how it is for me. Edited August 2 by Selegend
Mocha Posted August 2 Posted August 2 demi's earlier abums are weaker than miley's, but they are now on equal footing especially after demi's TYLM > Holy **** streak. If Miley hadn't released Plastic Hearts I would even say Demi edges her out
TaylorsSquad Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Was going to argue for Miley but I think I use 'Here We Go Again' more than any Miley Album so
crymelanie Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Holy **** is better than any miley album except for plastic hearts and mileys last effort to get a pop bible was kinda lame with that quality (i forgot the albums name sorry) 1 1
Miley Cyrus Posted August 2 Posted August 2 (edited) Demi wishes. And this is just a handful of singles mind you. Y'all can continue to gag over neon lights and heart attack tho. Edited August 2 by Miley Cyrus 1
Freakshowvato Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Here We Go Again and Tell Me You Love Me alone. This is facts, but I never found Miley's discography appealing.
Freakshowvato Posted August 3 Posted August 3 6 hours ago, Miley Cyrus said: Demi wishes. And this is just a handful of singles mind you. Y'all can continue to gag over neon lights and heart attack tho. Heart Attack is a masterpiece
Minto Posted August 3 Posted August 3 (edited) demi's catalogue is better than miley and throw in selena too tmylm, holy **** and hwga are a trinity the other girls really are not seeing Edited August 3 by Minto 2 1 2
YourFavoriteWeapon Posted August 3 Posted August 3 12 hours ago, corotinho said: No LOL Actually Demi has some bops but when you look at her album tracks, most are so random and weak. Miley also has a problem with that, but i guess Miley has stronger body of works when it comes to full albums. Demi's album tracks are better than most of her singles. Two Worlds Collide, Falling Over Me, Catch Me, For the Love of a Daughter, Nightingale, Wildfire, Cry Baby, The Way You Don't Look At Me, Carefully, EAT ME…all classics. Going back to the topic at hand, I don't think Demi's discography is stronger than Miley's. They're both equally talented when it comes to vocals and songwriting, but Miley's music usually has better production and is more interesting and risky. 1
Bey_Rihstan Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Demi is more consistent while Miley has (Much) higher Highs and lower lows. Demi doesn't have an album as good as Bangerz, Plastic Hearts or She is Coming, but she doesn't have as many Mid albums either. Overall, Miley's best is much better than Demi's and she has legit classics, so for me, she gets the win
enchanted0 Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Miley has a good amount of classics but yeah she has like one good album. So I agree with the OP 1
rhaenyra Posted August 3 Posted August 3 (edited) The difference here is Demi's discography started off great then steadily has gotten worse throughout her sizzling career While Miley's started off good then just kept getting better and better and her status bigger and bigger Miley is the clear winner here Edited August 3 by rhaenyra 1 1
liquiddiamonds Posted August 3 Posted August 3 (edited) Demi peaked with her Disney records tbh Miley continues to surprise, even when not everything lands. She has taken way more risks and has great deep cuts. I'd skip songs even in a Demi Greatest Hits album… Edited August 3 by liquiddiamonds
Freakshowvato Posted August 3 Posted August 3 56 minutes ago, rhaenyra said: The difference here is Demi's discography started off great then steadily has gotten worse throughout her sizzling career While Miley's started off good then just kept getting better and better and her status bigger and bigger Miley is the clear winner here I disagree. Demi's last three albums Tell Me You Love Me, Dancing with the Devil The Art of Starting Over, and HOLYFVCK are all strong records. Demi had more "generic" records with Confident, Unbroken, and DEMI, but her last three are similar to her Disney albums, in that they are outstanding and showcase true artistry. I think Demi has consistently MUCH better albums than Miley, but this is only my opinion. I do agree that Miley takes more risks (with more failures) and that her records can be deemed "more interesting", but which is better? It's Demi's
Freakshowvato Posted August 3 Posted August 3 And if we're talking SINGLES, then I'd say Miley's are better. But deep cuts and album tracks? It's a no brainer. Like people said Here We Go Again is the strongest Disney record by any Disney act... easily.
Robburro Posted August 3 Posted August 3 22 hours ago, Selegend said: Hard to tell. From a personal point of view: I like Miley more than i like Demi and Miley highs are wayy higher (she has some classicssss) but she also does have the worst consistancy among ex acts. Like, u never know if u're going to listen to the best song u have ever heard or the worst song u have ever heard when it comes to Miley. This is how it is for me. 10 hours ago, Bey_Rihstan said: Demi is more consistent while Miley has (Much) higher Highs and lower lows. Demi doesn't have an album as good as Bangerz, Plastic Hearts or She is Coming, but she doesn't have as many Mid albums either. Overall, Miley's best is much better than Demi's and she has legit classics, so for me, she gets the win actually yeah this I widely prefer Miley but she's the perfect definition of someone who's going to release either a really good song or either a really bad song
Teen Spirit Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Correct. Miley has two good songs: Party in the U.S.A. & Wrecking Ball. (23 is a cute dance bop).
Recommended Posts