base talk Me Against the Music vs Telephone

[Josh]

[tost1]

I love both so much

[Gladiator]

Telephone for both. 

Surprised the song itself isn't a poll question. I prefer Me Against the Music as a song over Telephone, which I actually don't really like.

 

Edited July 29 by Gladiator

[AxelFox]

Me Against The Music.

 

It's crazy how internet homosexuals have collectively deluded themselves into thinking Telephone is any good.

 

What a stain on Beyonce's body of work. No wonder she pretends it never existed. 

[ChooseyLover]

Me Against the Music is my favourite music video of all time. I saw the premiere on MTV as a kid... I was shocked and gagged and just completely in awe of the visuals and the dancing and seeing Madonna and Britney together in black and white suits resembling a chess game. Some Britney fans hate on MATM because it wasn't the huge hit you would expect from a Queen and Princess of Pop joint and that's a shame.

 

I can imagine many feel the same admiration/nostalgia for Telephone tho.

Edited July 29 by ChooseyLover

[itshyolee]

3 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

Me Against The Music.

 

It's crazy how internet homosexuals have collectively deluded themselves into thinking Telephone is any good.

 

What a stain on Beyonce's body of work. No wonder she pretends it never existed. 

Oh not too much on Telephone. It was a moment in pop culture .

 

 

[tost1]

11 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

Me Against The Music.

 

It's crazy how internet homosexuals have collectively deluded themselves into thinking Telephone is any good.

 

What a stain on Beyonce's body of work. No wonder she pretends it never existed. 

It's crazy how you think your opinion is worth more than that of other internet homosexuals

[Josh]

33 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

Me Against The Music.

 

It's crazy how internet homosexuals have collectively deluded themselves into thinking Telephone is any good.

 

What a stain on Beyonce's body of work. No wonder she pretends it never existed. 

Not when Best Thing I Never Had and Video Phone exist. 

Edited July 29 by Josh

[Asparagus Spears]

The production on me against the music is more interesting to me. The choreography is way better than telephone but that's to be expected from 2 exceptional dancers. But telephone has the better video obviously because it's a spectacle 

[Pepo]

Telephone aged better and is more iconic imo.

[Avenger]

Telephone is more popular for sure but my heart lies with MATM, I just love love love the video and the song the dancing in the video is immaculate. 

[BlackoutZone]

MATM choreo is insane and their looks in suits, whew

[RideOrDie]

godlyphone sweetie 

[Erreur2 La Nature]

I love both.

Telephone is a better song but MA has the better video and choregraphy.

Edited July 29 by Erreur2 La Nature

[Homebrand]

Video: Telephone for sure. Its camp but in all the best ways. 

 

Choreo: MATM. That Janet coded choreo on Brit is just so good

 

Song: MATM easily. Very underrated in her discography. Telephone was great for its time but I have to say it didn't really age the best for me 

[Princess Aurora]

Both but Telephone is more iconic. 

[JoeAg]

Telephone remains one of Gaga's best songs  and the MV and choreo are both perfection as well 

 

I like Me Against the Music but it's not quite as replayable as Telephone. the MV and choreo are nice

[Rev8]

Video is arguable

both are very cute, I love the dark aesthetic of MATM

while also love the poppish colors of Telephone

 

 

for Choreo..

MATM is a banger, love the style and everything

Telephone is something that gays will very much like, not that there is anything bad about that, I like it

it is really addicting so I understand why ATRL may chose it..but MATM is superior imo

[sunbathinganimal]

yes Telephone yes internet homosexuals

 

[AxelFox]

3 hours ago, Josh said:

Not when Best Thing I Never Had and Video Phone exist. 

Those too as well 

[Robyn.]

In terms of choreography? Definitely MATM. They literally hate so bad, I'd argue it is one of Britney's best dance routines.

 

 

[ericcartman]

Neither song is good but Telephone is probably more iconic and remembered.

[shyboi]

when Britney is involved, no else can compete, so my vote goes to Britney in both categories 

 

 

[Enrique523]

Oh, the thread is about the videos? I thought it would be about the songs themselves 

[UnusualBoy]

As a video Telephone is better but MATM has easily the best choreo.