base talk rank MPG worst selling album from most to least successful eras

[supertiffany]

Adele - 30

Ariana - Eternal Sunshine

Beyonce - Cowboy Carter

Britney - Glory

Gaga - Joanne

Katy - Smile

Rihanna - Music of the Sun

Taylor - Evermore

 

 

 

so which era of those girls has the best and most successful era

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Most succesful: 30

Least succesful: Glory

[MalibuBarbiieDelish]

All great albums but understandable why they're the least popular for each artist

[Sailor Moon]

Most: 30

Least: Smile

 

Too bad cause some of these albums are really good, it's just the circumstances that didn't allow them to reach their maximum.

[Minto]

30 being her least successful is crazy  a behemoth artist

 

Most successful: 30

 

Least successful: Glory

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Is there a reason why so many MPG (Madonna, Mariah, Janet, JLo, X-Tina, Miley, Selena, Shakira, Nicki, Dua and more...) are being ignored ? 

 

OT: I'm not ranking Ariana's and Beyoncé's latest album, they've literally been released like two months ago it's too early.

 

1. Adele - 30
2. Taylor - Evermore
3. Gaga - Joanne
4. Britney - Glory
5. Rihanna - Music of the Sun
6. Katy - Smile

Adele's 30 is the only truly successful era from this list so it's hard to rank the rest.

[dopamina]

Most successful:

30
Evermore

 

Least successful:
Smile
Glory

[zoldyck]

Most: 30

Least: Glory

[UnusualBoy]

Most: 30

Least: Glory or Smile

[By the Water]

ES is definitely more successful than YT though.

 

30 has the biggest hit but evermore is the one with the most units so I guess it depends on what you prefer. Joanne, Smile and Glory are the bottom 3, unsurprisingly.

Edited July 19 by By the Water

[ScorpiosGroove]

26 minutes ago, MalibuBarbiieDelish said:

All great albums but understandable why they're the least popular for each artist

who said cowboy carter's beyoncé's least popular album ? 

[TS Schönberg]

Lady Gaga should've released Joanne as an EP.

 

Diamond Heart to Sinner's Pray is a perfect run, the other half is bland and uninspiring. Wouldn't be mad if the EP has an deluxe version with Grigio girls and Just another day.

[ariananext]

ES is a lot bigger than Yours Truly, and it shouldn't be included considering it's 4 months old 

[Mr. Duff]

1. 30

2. Evermore

3. Eternal Sunshine

 

 

The rest has not held up well. Maybe it's still early for ES but it held up much better than Cowboy Carter.

 

The least is probably between Glory, Smile and Music of the Sun. At least MOTS had the smash hit Pon de Replay, and Katy's mildly successful with Never Really Over and Harleys in Hawaii.

[bielneira]

30 > eternal sunshine > evermore > Joanne = COWBOY CARTER > Music Of The Sun > Smile > Glory

Edited July 19 by bielneira

[CherryBay]

Adele and Gaga

[Xtripped]

30/ Glory

[ericcartman]

Adele or Taylor obviously most

 

Britney obviously least

[blueberries]

30

evermore

eternal sunshine

cowboy carter

joanne

music of the sun

smile

glory

[A-V-XYZ]

Most: 30

Least: Glory