base talk NYT: "reputation is the best Taylor Swift album"

[Raphy23]

1. Red

2. Evermore

3. Folklore

4. Speak Now

5. 1989

6. Midnights

the rest

11. TTPD

Edited July 18 by Raphy23

[Aaron]

I actually agree  Reputation is her best, evermore has always sucked, and Midnights is right behind it in the bottom two. 

[TaggedGalaxy]

Of course a reputationer would lack taste and proudly broadcast their lack of taste to the world 

[kellysclarkson]

1 hour ago, JasonGosling said:

Just listened to the whole podcast. I think his companion on the show might have better taste and judgement on the music (though he rated 1989 so low). 

Agree. This is the other guy's ranking for anyone curious:

 

11. 'Midnights'

10. 'THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT'

9. '1989'

8. 'evermore'

7. 'reputation'

6. 'Lover'

5. 'Taylor Swift'

4. 'Red'

3. 'Fearless'

2. 'folklore'

1. 'Speak Now'

[Støned]

Switch the best and the worst album, and you have a good ranking list. 

[Støned]

6 minutes ago, kellysclarkson said:

11. 'Midnights'

10. 'THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT'

9. '1989'

8. 'evermore'

7. 'reputation'

6. 'Lover'

5. 'Taylor Swift'

4. 'Red'

3. 'Fearless'

2. 'folklore'

1. 'Speak Now'

Great list! He's obviously a fan of country Taylor. and Lover being her best pop album 

[DirtyPony87]

What is this list? Literally none of it makes sense. 💀

[Jpkun]

This list is crazy

[Abracadabra]

Wait, they put her debut and TTPD ahead of Folklore and 1989? NURSE

[Mr. Duff]

I mean, should we really take this seriously?  

[G.U.Y_Del_Rey]

This must be one of the worst rankings I've ever seen

Edited July 18 by G.U.Y_Del_Rey

[By the Water]

A reputa stan with no taste? Groundbreaking!

[MidnightsAtPeace]

it's wild knowing that everGOD is her magnum opus and her best album, and reputation is her worst by far 

[SweetOreosOfHeaven]

Have they heard PTSD?

Spoiler

Me neither

 

 

[no_better]

Wtf? Is this guy on some hot crack ass ****?

 

And I used to think he was cute 

[Sadie Saxton]

Folklore at #9

 

1989 below Self titled

 

Fearless at #2
 

TTPD far too high

 

 

[UnusualBoy]

Folklore #9?

 

Girl, pls...

[SimpleKindofLife]

This is obviously a troll list

[Tayman]

The way he couldn´t be more wrong. 

How her worst album Lover is higher than her bests folklore and evermore? 

 

Edited July 18 by Tayman

[Jay07]

7 hours ago, NextBish90 said:

It proves they haven't heart her last one - TTPD. And also proving point that this ''record breaking'' album is nothing outside of her cult fanbase of toddlers, 12s and some weird gay Swifties getting into trouples and asking ATRL for orgy advices. 

[Vixen Eyes]

7 hours ago, Feanor said:

11. 'evermore'

10. 'Midnights'

9. 'folklore'

8. 'Lover'

7. '1989'

6. 'Taylor Swift'

5. 'THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT'

4. 'RED'

3. 'Speak Now'

2. 'Fearless'

1. 'reputation'

Id move TTPD last and move Lover right in front of it and switch 1989 and self titled  but otherwise its loosely correct

[BadHabits]

8 hours ago, Bocanada said:

When Lover is just here... 

There's good songs like:

 

1. Cruel Summer

2. Lover

3. The Man

4. Paper Rings

5. Soon You'll Get Better

6. You Need To Calm Down

7. Me! 

 

I do think the album is way too long at overstuffed at 18 tracks. Maybe 12 track standard + 3 song deluxe. 

[BadHabits]

8 hours ago, Feanor said:

 

We heard about which album NYT music critic Jon Caramanica picked as the best Taylor Swift album…

 

And in this same video, starting at around the 14:00 mark, he also proclaims 'evermore' as Taylor Swift's worst album "by a rather large margin". Is the NYT correct in their assessment?

 

His full ranking for those interested:

 

11. 'evermore'

10. 'Midnights'

9. 'folklore'

8. 'Lover'

7. '1989'

6. 'Taylor Swift'

5. 'THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT'

4. 'RED'

3. 'Speak Now'

2. 'Fearless'

1. 'reputation'

 

 

TTPD is no better than 1989 and Folklore and Evermore, they're like 3 of her best albums. Midnights and Lover should be higher.

 

1. Folklore

2. 1989

3. Evermore

4. Red

5. Midnights

6. Fearless

7. Reputation

8. Lover

9. Speak Now

10. The Tortured Poets Department

11. Taylor Swift

[ChrisTheLoner]

Reputa being #1, maybe some taste jumped out

 

 

Evermore is definitely not her worst though tf 

[Chris]

What is this f*cking **** that I am reading?

 

Evermore is her worst album?

 

Is this a joke?

 

Satire?