base talk NYT: "reputation is the best Taylor Swift album"

[Klein]

Lover? Above folklore and evermore? It's worse than the little bits I actually saw from this video. 

 

At least he got 4 of the top 6 right (just not necessarily in the right order). 

[Illuminati]

Folklore at the bottom too That's quite a hot take

[Alldeezy]

I mean they ain't wrong

[Blue.]

It is her best by a large margin, NYT should fire him for lacking criteria

[flashfox]

No album can be worse than lover I fear.

[Kiss It Better]

when The Tortured is right there.....

[Gagaast]

Evermore at 11 and Folklore at 9? while Taylor Swift at 6 and TTDP at 5? Rotten taste.

 

Seriously?

2. 'Fearless'

1. 'reputation'

[KatyPrismSpirit]

1. RED

2. Midnights

3. folklore

4. 1989

5. Reputation

6. Speak Now

7. Fearless

8. The Tortured Poets Department

9. Lover

10. evermore

11. Debut 

 

[PoisonedIvy]

What in tarnation is that ranking  

 

evermore last is a violation of the Geneva Convention btw

[Squall]

Tragic taste but are we surprised?

[Gladiator]

oh that's not

[ariananext]

[BOAZ]

I think her worst album is tied between Debut and Lover tbh, with Midnights close nearby 

 

10. Debut/Lover

9. Midnights

8. Speak Now

7. Tortured Poets

6. evermore

5. Fearless

4. Reputation

3. 1989

2. Red

1. folklore

 

Edited July 18 by BOAZ

[diemoehre]

Aren't those videos only to bait engagement?

[Blackout2006]

Unless we are classifying the tattooed Golden Retriever album as a mixtape which to be fair, would be justified; Evermore is nowhere near that spot.

[Blackout2006]

All the cool swifties I know have Reputation in their top three so yes. Reputation = cool

[Into The Void]

Evermore her biggest snooze fest is where it belongs. Lol. 1989 deserves higher though. I was a fan of folklore at first but got bored of it quickly so I don't mind it towards the bottom. I think this is a good list tbh

Edited July 18 by Into The Void

[xperience30]

That's why I don't care at all about critics . Evermore is pure gold 

[Breakdown]

how can a list be so ******* wrong in every way. and evermore is one of her very best

[TMRA]

53 minutes ago, Feanor said:

His full ranking for those interested:

 

11. 'evermore'

10. 'Midnights'

9. 'folklore'

8. 'Lover'

7. '1989'

6. 'Taylor Swift'

5. 'THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT'

4. 'RED'

3. 'Speak Now'

2. 'Fearless'

1. 'reputation

Me when I smoke crack:

[kellebrity98]

1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

i agree it's one of her worst albums

yes, it's so boring

[PerfectCure]

Evermore is her last good album.

[Cruel Summer]

Genuinely one of the worst, dumbest pop music takes I have ever seen in my life - and I'm an ATRL member.

[vale9001]

It's just men reevaluating it (same journalist gave it a 7 when it came) cause the set on the eras tour is very hard rock (a reviewer of the show in Italy definied the set like this and another one wrote is the punk set of the show).

 

I agree on the eras tour Rep sounds great, It's a shame the album is not like that but (mostly) bland electro pop. I hope the new version is not full karaoke but adds more guitars. 

Edited July 18 by vale9001

[Rep2000]

1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

i agree it's one of her worst albums

Wbk that you have no taste, dear.