poll Better discography: Kelly vs. Pink

[naval23]

Who had the superior 2000s discography?

 

Kelly: Thankful (2003), Breakaway (2004), My December (2007), All I Ever Wanted (2009)
Pink: Can't Take Me Home (2000), M!ssundaztood (2001), Try This (2003), I'm Not Dead (2006), Funhouse (2008)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The superior 2010s/2020s discography?

 

 

 

Kelly: Stronger (2011), Piece by Piece (2015), Meaning of Life (2017), Chemistry (2022)

Pink: The Truth About Love (2012), Beautiful Trauma (2017), Hurts 2B Human (2019), Trustfall (2023)

 

Overall discography?

[selena_lavigne]

They are actually extremely comparable and it's Kelly. 

[CherryBay]

Kelly x3

[Popboi.]

Kelly 00s and 20s, pretty tied in the 10s (P!no bigger highs but lower lows).

[UnusualBoy]

00s goes to Kelly

10s goes to Alecia

 

Overall it's hard but since I've played more Kelly, I'll go with her.

[Princess Aurora]

2000s Kelly's discography is amazing but the 2010s go to P!nk

[Migs]

2000s: P!nk

2010s: Kelly

Overall: Kelly 

[orange22]

This is tough. Thinking Kelly, Legend P, Kelly. But Alecia puts up a fight for the 2000's.

 

Edited July 17 by orange22

[Nico Robin]

Pr!ncess is taking it but Kelly's great too

[Vixen Eyes]

P!nk

Kelly

Kelly

but i love them both equally

[Technicolor]

The Who Knew songstress

Edited July 17 by Technicolor

[rock]

P!nk for all. Kelly's good to, but will never be a bigger artist than P!nk and that's ok.

[ArtForFreedom]

They're very comparable but I give Pink the edge as she is more hands on 

[Bloo]

Kelly for all. I think Kelly vs. Pink is more competitive in the 2000s, but I prefer BA to P!nk's Misundaztood and MD is something P!nk has not touched for me. That album is one of my favorites. As for the 2010s, MOL washes all of P!nk's efforts from the 2010s.

[lelewlovebird]

For the 2000's I find it more difficult but I think I'd give it to Kelly (MD is one of my favorite albums) but for 10's it's definitely Kelly for me. Stronger is a nice evolution from the 2000's pop rock albums, honestly I don't find PBP very remarkable but MOL was good and was a solid step in a new direction for Kelly and there's a handful of tracks on Chemistry that I think stand out and push her in a direction she hadn't fully gone before (Skip This Part, Mine, title track, etc.). Most of P!nk's material from 10's-now doesn't really add much to her overall discography for me, a couple of good tracks per album and then I largely forget the rest (apart from TTAL which I like).

[Sabandija]

I was for Kelly Rowland so I'd say Pink.

[YourFavoriteWeapon]

Their highs are equal but P!nk has much lower lows 

[Ger]

Kelly, in fact her discography is highly underrated.

[JoeAg]

oh I love the poll options tbh 

 

overall definitely goes to Kelly, every single album of hers ends up having major discography highlights. she's crazy consistent, and once you open up to Chemistry you realize it's one of her best projects. P!nk has not been NEARLY as consistent, which is why it's always been easier to stan Kelly over her. they're both underappreciated and strong pop songwriters, and both are S tier vocalists. when it comes to their experimental flops, My December DEVOURS Try This. Try This is cute, and has Catch Me While I'm Sleeping and Trouble and Feel Good Time which are three of her best songs, but I was expecting more when I heard people compare it to the alt rock masterwork that is My December. it's quite uneven. My December on the other hand is evergreen. dgmw, P!nk's run from I'm Not Dead to The Truth About Love is ELITE and one of the best pop album 1-2-3 punches ever if we're being honest, but Kelly overall has more classics. so while P!nk has 4 incredible albums (shoutout to M!ssundaztood as well as aforementioned run of 3!), Kelly has Breakaway, My December, All I Ever Wanted, Stronger, Meaning of Life, and Chemistry which are all TOP TIER pop albums. 6 brilliant > 4 brilliant. so I have to give all 3 to Kelly  while I rarely return to Thankful and Piece by Piece, both are still solid. they're just more dated generally than the other 6 albums. god lemme give Breakaway and All I Ever Wanted some streams today, both are so f*cking amazing and I don't return to them enough lately 

[Mr. Duff]

Both are amazing and have great discographies. I voted Kelly for 00s, Pink for 10s/20s and Kelly overall. But really, they are both excellent.

[Escape]

P!nk has Secrets so her

[blueberries]

kelly by far

[supertiffany]

Overall Kelly:

 

good albums and better singles

 

 

[Reginald]

Honestly, the BlackP!nk eras were full of timeless r&b-pop bops  Whenever she wants to go back to making that kind of music, I will stan 

 

Edited July 19 by Reginald

[Nashe]

Kelly definitely for all, but I voted P!nk for overall by mistake