poll Bigger in 2024: Katy Perry or Charli XCX

[tomo]

Global Spotify

Woman's World - #58-OUT

360 - #112 (36 days on chart)

 

US Spotify

Woman's World - #110-OUT

360 - #62 (43 days on chart)

 

 

[Sugden]

brat did almost 9m yesterday like 2 months after release

katy will be lucky if her album does this on the debut day

[Illuminati]

Katy is more comparable to Iggy in 2024 imo

[Curaga]

Katy might be getting more (bad) attention for WW/143, but Miss XCX has left a much longer-lasting mark with the brat era

So I'm gonna say Charli!

[VeniceBeach]

Not me accidentally picking Katy and ruining a perfect 100% for Charli 

[TeemoR]

omg how dare you

 

Charli released possibly the best album of the year.

[mercurialworld]

the unanimous voting for charli other than the mistake clarified by the user above 😭 

[Princess Aurora]

[stars]

I mean, you answered your question with those stats 

[Epica]

Sorry I mistook my vote. She's still 0/0

[Dear Reader]

easily brat 

[heckinglovato]

Charli XCX is bigger amongst a niche group of Gen Z gays and female allies of the gay bottom community. If you'll ask anyone outside this group they'll immediately recognize Katy more despite not having a proper hit for over a decade

 

Charli still hasn't cracked enough into the mainstream 

[Phaunzie]

One is a household name, something Charli is not. So Katy.

[Illyboy]

Is this really a question?

[zoldyck]

Camila would be far better fair comparison for Katy in 2024

[Breakdown]

Katy Perry is still a household name unlike Charli who is only known to LGBTQ social media users which is perfectly reflected in their Spotify monthly listeners:

 

Katy: 57.1m

 

 

---------

Barrier

---------

 

Kesha 35.3m

 

 

 

Charli 21.9m

[Miracle]

Charli XCX has been more relevant than Katy Perry since 2020 lol

 

Yes she doesn't have thst kine of throwback era nostalgia or playlisting (nor her songs are as generic as Katy Perry's discography) so her Spotify numbers might be worse overall but Charli is way bigger 

Edited July 14 by Miracle

[Onyxmage]

Realistically Katy is still more known than Charli.

[Onyxmage]

37 minutes ago, Breakdown said:

Katy Perry is still a household name unlike Charli who is only known to LGBTQ social media users which is perfectly reflected in their Spotify monthly listeners:

 

Katy: 57.1m

 

 

---------

Barrier

---------

 

Kesha 35.3m

 

 

 

Charli 21.9m

As a charli fan I agree. 

[TayDuaStan]

Currently Charli is bigger than Katy. Brat debuted at #3 with 77k units (and it's actually stable on the B200). Katy's last album barely did 50k and served #5 - OUT & she'll be extremely lucky to have 143 debut inside the Top 50 (based on how bad WW is doing) 

[Wewee]

[stevyy]

2 hours ago, TayDuaStan said:

Currently Charli is bigger than Katy. Brat debuted at #3 with 77k units (and it's actually stable on the B200). Katy's last album barely did 50k and served #5 - OUT & she'll be extremely lucky to have 143 debut inside the Top 50 (based on how bad WW is doing) 

what a false comment... 

 

Charli cannot be bigger... Katy still has her career to fall back on. TD is currently charting in many markets. 

[TayDuaStan]

27 minutes ago, stevyy said:

what a false comment... 

 

Charli cannot be bigger... Katy still has her career to fall back on. TD is currently charting in many markets. 

The title says: "Bigger in 2024" not "bigger overall" or "bigger 10 years ago". Like it or not, in 2024, Charli's career is more successful currently than Katy's 

Edited July 14 by TayDuaStan

[stevyy]

2 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said:

The title says: "Bigger in 2024" not "bigger overall" or "bigger 10 years ago". Like it or not, in 2024, Charli's career is more successful currently than Katy's 

TD is charting right now...that's 2024.

[Nightingale]

Ehh at the end of the day Katy will always have her catalogue and can tour off of that and have Vegas shows or get paid millions to sit on an American Idol judge chair even if her album isn't doing as great as Charli's one hit album