Popular Post EnigmaticAndroid Posted July 12 Popular Post Posted July 12 18 hours ago, VeniceBeach said: Katy's song is so bad it makes Stupid Love sound like a masterpiece 18 hours ago, Reginald said: They are two of the songs of all time 17 hours ago, Bimbo said: I'm being so serious when I say I thought nothing in 2024 could be worse than Stupid Love... but she managed to. 17 hours ago, Konril said: The good thing is, Woman's World was not shot in an iPhone. At least there's an acceptable winner in one aspect. 16 hours ago, frankvert said: Stupid Love, arguably one of the WORST songs Gaga has ever released, washes the floor with that cheap, carbon copied, rip off 15 hours ago, FrederickGa said: How could you make STUPID LOVE sound like a great pop song 8 hours ago, sunbathinganimal said: not the Stupid Noise landslide ijbol 7 hours ago, TMRA said: WW sounds like a jojo siwa song, childlish, cringe and doesnt belong in 2024. Truly a horrible bland song. SL isnt a good song too but its miles better than WW. WW has a better video but still not a very good video 5 hours ago, Marry The Gods said: Both are horrible but I think stupid love wins by a speck. You just made that up dear. It's giving amnesia. Nurse! 18
Konril Posted July 12 Posted July 12 2 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: You just made that up dear. It's giving amnesia. Nurse! Come on Miss Android. I never f****d with the Stupid Love video. Sonically, Stupid Love is better though. 1
Pheromosa Posted July 12 Posted July 12 Any praise its getting is at Katy's expense so it doesn't really count. But to their defense I did see a lot of them defending that song when it was new
Richie.Valdez Posted July 12 Posted July 12 Both songs are trash, let's not pretend a half-solid dump is better than diarrhea.
EnigmaticAndroid Posted July 12 Posted July 12 Just now, Konril said: Come on Miss Android. I never ****** with the Stupid Love video. Sonically, StupidnLove is better though. Not Miss Android sksksksk 1
Enzo Posted July 12 Posted July 12 I mean, it's been years since its release Of course it might have grown on some people But then again, monsters are still hating on it til this day lmao
robattack332 Posted July 12 Posted July 12 We are the biggest Stupid Love haters!! We didn't think someone could make it even worse which is that insanity of WW. 2
Vegvisir Posted July 12 Posted July 12 ATRL is the ONLY place you see this narrative that Stupid Love is/was a bomb. People were gagged when it leaked, and despite it being out there for over a month before the official release it STILL charted in the Top 10. It isn't one of Gaga's BEST tracks, but it's far from the worst. ATRL is such a vacuum of hot takes and doesn't reflect reality lmao
Bimbo Posted July 12 Posted July 12 22 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: You just made that up dear. It's giving amnesia. Nurse! Ouuu don't clock poor OP like that 3
Konril Posted July 12 Posted July 12 If OP steps inside the Monster Base you would know the things that propel the Base into muliple pages are: 1. Stupid Love slander 2. Rankings 3. Sarah Tanno catching strays. 1 2
Digitalism Posted July 12 Author Posted July 12 24 minutes ago, EnigmaticAndroid said: You just made that up dear. It's giving amnesia. Nurse! Girl I have job. I don't have time to search for the comments saying time is the ultimate teller and the critics finally saw the light. Maybe you can do it since it seems you have a lot of free time in your hands
ThePopStop Posted July 12 Posted July 12 With Gaga still holding my stan card, I have no problem saying that Stupid Love was as underwhelming of a comeback single for Gaga as Woman's World is to me for Katy. They're not bad songs, but incredibly average and boring. And yet Katy and Gaga seem to think it's their opus magnum? I think we're seeing the effects of them being surrounded by "yes people."
jordanjm Posted July 12 Posted July 12 Deflecting to a song released over 4 years ago that was generally liked (not loved) will not make WW a better song. I do love the switch up of focus by Kats from chart performance to quality, something Katy has never particularly excelled at.
EnigmaticAndroid Posted July 12 Posted July 12 (edited) 22 minutes ago, Digitalism said: Girl I have job. I don't have time to search for the comments saying time is the ultimate teller and the critics finally saw the light. Maybe you can do it since it seems you have a lot of free time in your hands 1. YOU are the person who made a thread saying that Liddos are pretending to like Stupid Love currently, implying that you've seen comments made by them recently on the subject. 2. These are all quoted from the same thread. I read them before I commented in the thread. It took 2 minutes. 3. Sorry you got clocked for threading something brazenly dumb. Edited July 12 by EnigmaticAndroid 7
ATRL Moderator MissedTheTrain Posted July 12 ATRL Moderator Posted July 12 I've never hated it and I stand by saying it's not nearly as bad as people pretend it is. For someone whose lead singles always had a little bit of something unusual about them, Stupid Love is definitely the most basic and safest single of her career, but her vocals on it kind of save it. 1
Digitalism Posted July 12 Author Posted July 12 34 minutes ago, Vegvisir said: ATRL is the ONLY place you see this narrative that Stupid Love is/was a bomb. People were gagged when it leaked, and despite it being out there for over a month before the official release it STILL charted in the Top 10. It isn't one of Gaga's BEST tracks, but it's far from the worst. ATRL is such a vacuum of hot takes and doesn't reflect reality lmao @EnigmaticAndroid it's literally in this thread too. Sorry about your eye problems. Get well soon luv
Namiskine Posted July 12 Posted July 12 I myself quoted 'Stupid Love' recently in a thread titled 'Songs so bad you thought they were a joke' or something like that. But it's still MILES better than the trashy 2024 rehash version made in collaboration with a r*pist.
Robyn. Posted July 12 Posted July 12 Stupid Love was a hard first listen... But nowadays it grew on me. Although that video is by far HER WORST. It looks like a parody.
Mr. Stratus Posted July 12 Posted July 12 1 hour ago, Digitalism said: I still remember the meltdowns when it leaked, when it was confirmed to be the single, when the video was released and when it underperformed. Now after the Katy Pitchfork review they are acting like have always liked it and now it's getting it's flowers. Do some of you really fake like your favs' music? This just reads as your pressedness cause as a Madonna Brit Stan you couldn't use Katy in the way you wanted. She's no longer yours to beat Gaga with! and no, we always had a 70% - 30% like, but at least WWs made it look better 2 1
enchanted0 Posted July 12 Posted July 12 51 minutes ago, Vegvisir said: ATRL is the ONLY place you see this narrative that Stupid Love is/was a bomb. People were gagged when it leaked, and despite it being out there for over a month before the official release it STILL charted in the Top 10. It isn't one of Gaga's BEST tracks, but it's far from the worst. ATRL is such a vacuum of hot takes and doesn't reflect reality lmao I guess that's why it was extremely stable on Spotify (which was a very good sign) 1
ATRL Moderator Juánny Posted July 12 ATRL Moderator Posted July 12 This is a psychological phenomenon called the contrast effect So some people could theoretically like Stupid Love more by listening to Woman's World. Katy is so kind 2
Recommended Posts