Lagerfeld Posted July 10 Posted July 10 If we look at singers like Lady Gaga, Beyoncé, Taylor Swift, Nicki Minaj, Katy Perry, Madonna, Rihanna, etc.. they seem to have dedicated stans that are willing to fight the stan fight for them. However, when you turn the page to pop girls like Sabrina, Olivia, Billie, etc. it's radio silence. Dua had some stans but they've disappeared at the moment. Why do these girls lack the footing in stan culture? 3
Odette Violet Posted July 10 Posted July 10 the second and third ones has stanbases tho, not sure about the others
wish Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Hello? We're right here Spoiler Billie & Olivia's fanbases are alive and well on TikTok/Twitter. ATRL's demographic is just kinda falling out of touch 5
Josh Posted July 10 Posted July 10 7 minutes ago, Lagerfeld said: If we look at singers like Lady Gaga, Beyoncé, Taylor Swift, Nicki Minaj, Katy Perry, Madonna, Rihanna, etc.. they seem to have dedicated stans that are willing to fight the stan fight for them. However, when you turn the page to pop girls like Sabrina, Olivia, Billie, etc. it's radio silence. Dua had some stans but they've disappeared at the moment. Why do these girls lack the footing in stan culture? Why is Nicki in this list but not Britney?
Wicked Posted July 10 Posted July 10 All of those women have 'stans'. I'd say the fact they're in different lanes probably makes the need to be catty not as frequent. They do different things and are seeing success.
A-V-XYZ Posted July 10 Posted July 10 17 minutes ago, Josh said: Why is Nicki in this list but not Britney? Nicki's not retired.
futuresuperstar2023 Posted July 10 Posted July 10 They have stans but not crazy ones. This new generation is different. The star quality is just not the same tbh. There are talented new artist but the industry is microwavable now. The same thing goes for Movie stars. I blame social media and all these socia media stars tbh 1
byzantium Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Maybe Gen Z knows better than to waste so much of their time obsessing over millionaires. 7
BrattyBottom Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Olivia and Billie do have stans and a lot of them are just as rabid and unwell as the Barbz. 2
Josh Posted July 10 Posted July 10 (edited) 5 minutes ago, A-V-XYZ said: Nicki's not retired. She's still a pop girl with one of the biggest stan bases on here Rihanna's an Avon Lady you included her Edited July 10 by Josh 1
PoisonedIvy Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Stanhood is not a sustainable relationship for the fans nor the artists, it's bound to collapse entirely at some point. Hopefully we're overcoming the worst of it, those pop crave replies are truly the bane of the internet sometimes. 1
Josh Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Just now, PoisonedIvy said: Stanhood is not a sustainable relationship for the fans nor the artists, it's bound to collapse entirely at some point. Hopefully we're overcoming the worst of it, those pop crave replies are truly the bane of the internet sometimes. Swifties, Britney Army, BeyHive, Monsters are all active stan bases
Mocha Posted July 10 Posted July 10 (edited) some of these def have stanbases, we're just too old to meet them/interact with them irl now Edited July 10 by Mocha 1 4
PoisonedIvy Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Just now, Josh said: Swifties, Britney Army, BeyHive, Monsters are all active stan bases Yes and a non-zero percentage of these groups are vengeful, spiteful, immature, and sometimes prejudicial individuals that have no morals or boundaries preventing them from veering into harmful or even illegal activities at times solely in the name of defending their favorite artists.. I'm not saying being a fan of an artist will cease to exist (hello, I'm one) but -stanhood- as a phenomenon is slowly dying out. All the women you named debuted around 2010 or prior. It's a good sign that we don't have fanbases with the same fervor of the Hive or the Swifties or the Barbz, that's not good for humanity as a whole.. Most of stan culture has kind of shifted over to the east for K-pop anyway
RoseBud Posted July 10 Posted July 10 They have millions but you just don't see these teen girls on ATRL... 2
Eternium Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Billie Eilish not having stans? Girl, you're half a decade late 2 3
Katy V.! Posted July 10 Posted July 10 38 minutes ago, Mocha said: some of these def have stanbases, we're just too old to meet them/interact with them irl now This is the only correct answer. 1 1
IsidoraMarí Posted July 10 Posted July 10 Rihanna never had a sizeable stan base until after ANTi. She had mostly casual fans and a few die hards. Now everyone loves Rih, it'll take more than success to have a loyal fanbase that supports your music,
HardBambi Posted July 10 Posted July 10 All stans are already taken by the existing main girls, there's no one left to stan for new girls.
Recommended Posts