Acuminatus Posted July 8 Posted July 8 Easily Billie - she actually brought something new and the album made a huge impact on pop culture. The minimalist production is immaculate! So many Billie clones have tried to pop up in the years following. Chappell makes great pop music and is on her way to being a MPG, but her debut album is nothing that new or innovative, and it's basically a bunch of singles stapled together. Maybe the main unique aspect is that the lyrics are from a queer angle and she is bringing in drag inspired visuals? But visually what Billie brought for her era was great as well. In Chappell's defence, there hasn't been enough time to measure her impact, so we will have to come back to this debate in a couple of years. 2
Mtjjproducer Posted July 9 Posted July 9 i'm in the minority but i really don't like chappel's music that much. i'm still trying to get into her but so far just not. her music isn't "bad" imo it sounds like the band Muna's music but just not as good. i'm going to try and listen to the album again though 1
Sazare Posted July 9 Posted July 9 8 minutes ago, Mtjjproducer said: i'm in the minority but i really don't like chappel's music that much. i'm still trying to get into her but so far just not. her music isn't "bad" imo it sounds like the band Muna's music but just not as good. i'm going to try and listen to the album again though Trust your instincts tbh
potent Posted July 9 Posted July 9 bad guy vs Femininomenon xanny vs Red Wine Supernova you should see me in a crown vs After Midnight all the good girls go to hell vs Coffee wish you were gay vs Casual when the party's over vs Super Graphic Ultra Modern Girl 8 vs HOT TO GO! my strange addiction vs My Kink Is Karma bury a friend vs Picture You ilomilo vs Kaleidoscope listen before i go vs Pink Pony Club i love you vs Naked In Manhattan goodbye vs California Bonus: everything i wanted vs Guilty Pleasure According to this it's even lol Chappell's songs are catchier I think but Billie's sticks with me more. Both great though
Ken Lee Posted July 9 Posted July 9 bad guy vs. Femininomenon xanny vs. Red Wine Supernova you should see me in a crown vs. After Midnight all the good girls go to hell vs. Coffee wish you were gay vs. Casual when the party's over vs. Super Graphic Ultra Modern Girl 8 vs. HOT TO GO! my strange addiction vs. My Kink is Karma bury a friend vs. Picture You ilomilo vs. Kaleidoscope listen before i go vs. Pink Pony Club i love you vs Naked in Manhattan goodbye vs. California everything i wanted vs. Guilty Pleasure
burninredhot Posted July 9 Author Posted July 9 bad guy vs Femininomenon xanny vs Red Wine Supernova you should see me in a crown vs After Midnight all the good girls go to hell vs Coffee wish you were gay vs Casual when the party's over vs Super Graphic Ultra Modern Girl 8 vs HOT TO GO! my strange addiction vs My Kink Is Karma bury a friend vs Picture You ilomilo vs Kaleidoscope listen before i go vs Pink Pony Club i love you vs Naked In Manhattan goodbye vs California Bonus: everything i wanted vs Guilty Pleasure Billie - 5 Chappell - 9 for me
Invisibility Posted July 9 Posted July 9 bad guy vs Femininomenon xanny vs Red Wine Supernova you should see me in a crown vs After Midnight all the good girls go to hell vs Coffee wish you were gay vs Casual when the party's over vs Super Graphic Ultra Modern Girl 8 vs HOT TO GO! my strange addiction vs My Kink Is Karma bury a friend vs Picture You ilomilo vs Kaleidoscope listen before i go vs Pink Pony Club i love you vs Naked In Manhattan goodbye vs California everything i wanted vs Guilty Pleasure 7 vs 7 But the lows in Chappell's album (the non-Casual ballads) are lower than Billie's, so WWAFAWDWG wins for me
CottageHore Posted July 9 Posted July 9 Both are strong debuts but there's absolutely no reason Billie's album should be winning this poll against an album like TRAFOAMWP
Recommended Posts