Jump to content
Login issues ×
The ATRL Grammys are back! ×

Reminder of "viral" thresholds

B'Day vs I Am...Sasha Fierce

Brooklyn Baby

By Brooklyn Baby
in Base

 Share

B'Day vs I Am...Sasha Fierce  

54 members have voted

  1. 1. Which Beyoncé album is superior?


Recommended Posts

Brooklyn Baby Grand Master

Brooklyn Baby

Posted
Posted

816LJhBJIkL._UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg

 

71gO33uDjOL._UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg

 

 

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

Virgos Groove Grand Master

Virgos Groove

Posted
Posted

B'Day and it's not close. Like, not even remotely close. :deadbanana4:

  • Like 5
  • Thanks 4
Joaco95 Proficient

Joaco95

Posted
Posted

i am sasha fierce

also why are you using the messy deluxe tracklist?

  • Like 1
VerdantHue Proficient

VerdantHue

Posted
Posted

B'Day PERIOD!

getBusy Grand Master

getBusy

Posted
Posted

IASF has so many fillers that it kinda ruins it for me

 

QueenB Mentor

QueenB

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

 

I went in thinking B'day would clear but it turns out IA..SF is that girl 

:cm:

Pheromosa Grand Master

Pheromosa

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

(IASF is better though)

50thStateofMind Grand Master

50thStateofMind

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

 

BʻDay by a mile

Negiiiii Experienced

Negiiiii

Posted
Posted

Yall know what my answer is BYE

Batsy Armada Community Regular

Batsy Armada

Posted
Posted

I really do like IASF, but B'Day was such a magical moment and era. And I do feel like it has aged much better. I consider B'Day to be the quintessential album from Beyoncé, even still.

  • Thanks 1
Klein Grand Master

Klein

Posted
Posted

That seems a little insulting to B'Day. 

itshyolee Grand Master

itshyolee

Posted
Posted

B'Day will forever be that girl and is one of Bey's best albums.

 

IASF was a cute era, but I always felt that it was just something to fully establish Bey's status as a force to be reckoned with.

LVP Mentor

LVP

Posted
Posted

You mean her best album vs her worst?

  • Thumbs Down 1
Devin Grand Master

Devin

Posted
Posted
21 minutes ago, QueenB said:

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

reported asf. :biblio:

  • Haha 1
Janet Grand Master

Janet

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

 

11 v 5 

 

:suburban:

ariesgroove Veteran

ariesgroove

Posted
Posted

iasf should be embarrassed 

Joaco95 Proficient

Joaco95

Posted
Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, ariesgroove said:

iasf should be embarrassed 

to be compared with bdone? iktr

Edited by Joaco95
ariesgroove Veteran

ariesgroove

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, Joaco95 said:

to be compared with bdone? iktr

to exist!

 

spacer.png

 

Spoiler

the sasha fierce half is always an eat though :alexz2:

 

  • Thumbs Down 1
prézli Grand Master

prézli

Posted
Posted

B'Day for all. Her best album.

QueenB Mentor

QueenB

Posted
Posted
21 minutes ago, Devin said:

reported asf. :biblio:

to the good taste police? Because I don't see a problem here 

SoJro101 Proficient

SoJro101

Posted
Posted

9…4…8…1

  • Thanks 1
Beyonceist Experienced

Beyonceist

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

ChooseyLover Grand Master

ChooseyLover

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

13 vs. 3

:gaycat6::gaycat6::gaycat6:

ICLDXU4HS Grand Master

ICLDXU4HS

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

Carla Rosón Veteran

Carla Rosón

Posted
Posted

Beautiful Liar vs If I Were a Boy

Irreplaceable vs Halo

Green Light vs Disappear

Kitty Kat vs Broken-Hearted Girl

Welcome to Hollywood vs Ave Maria

Upgrade U vs Smash Into You

Flaws and All vs Satellites

World Wide Woman vs That's Why You're Beautiful

Get Me Bodied vs Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)

If vs Radio

Freakum Dress vs Diva

Suga Mama vs Sweet Dreams

Déjà Vu vs Video Phone

Ring the Alarm vs Hello

Resentment vs Ego

Listen vs Scared of Lonely

 Share
Go to topic listing

Obsessed with Pop Culture. Copyright © 1999-2024, ATRL

Navigation

About Us

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.