poll GGGB vs. Loud

[A Million Lights]

[Rino]

GGGB clears  it turned a previously unknown faceless girl to THEE Rihanna we know and love today

[Doctor Dick]

Loud had more smash hits and #1s and is the better album. 

[itshyolee]

GGGB because that era solidified Rih's status as a MPG and paved the way for Loud to even be made

[selena_lavigne]

Loud is miles better.

Push Up On Me

Breakin' Dishes

Lemme Get That

are bops though.

Edited Thursday at 02:29 AM by selena_lavigne

[dumbsparce]

LOUD for all. GGGB might have felt bigger but it was only bc of the stark difference in ccuunt compared to the mixtape eras.

 

Disturbia remains the greatest song of all time though.

[bielneira]

Good Girl Gone Bad
Good Girl Gone Bad
Loud

 

[nostalgic]

Loud is great with the exception of one song but it's so paint-by-numbers pop that it feels like anyone could have recorded most of those songs. I can't see anyone else having recorded the bulk of GGGB's tracks - it was her all the way and took her from a faceless clone of the other R&B girls of the time to a household name. That era felt like it would never end and just kept going - standard album, hit upon hit, Reloaded, GGGB Live, the remix album 

[crf13]

GGGB for all

[Alldeezy]

both great albums but GGGB is Rihanna's best and best pop album of the 2000s

[Kiss It Better]

GGGB for all, but Loud #1s are better than GGGB's #1s 

[Homebrand]

Bigger: GGGB (Reloaded) > Loud > GGGB

Better Singles: Ugh both? the only dud is Cheers

Better Album: GGGB for sure. Has some of the best deep cuts of her career like Sell My Candy, Lemme Get That and the title track

 

[A Million Lights]

11 hours ago, bielneira said:

Good Girl Gone Bad
Good Girl Gone Bad
Loud

 

This

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Loud easily