futuresuperstar2023 Posted July 3 Posted July 3 (edited) I think smile is. Witness is not her best album but I don't feel like it's as bad as people make it out to be. It was a flop era and devastating for the stans but the album was decent. Now Smile is rough. Edited July 3 by futuresuperstar2023
Popular Post Frappucino Posted July 3 Popular Post Posted July 3 This is an extremely tough decision to make given how bad both of these albums are 18
wastedpotential Posted July 3 Posted July 3 (edited) This immediately puts Witness on top. Nothing on Smule comes close Edited July 3 by wastedpotential 5
Bubble Tea Posted July 3 Posted July 3 Witness is absolutely jam packed with incredible bops. Smile has cute tracks but the whole thing was rather forgettable. I guess it came out during COVID-times so there wasn't much promo to underscore it all. 3
blown away Posted July 3 Posted July 3 Witness is an okay album, Smile however is horrendous. It maybe has 2 good songs on it. 2
WhateverYouWant Posted July 3 Posted July 3 (edited) Witness was garbage. Smile had NRO and HIH. Smile was poop too but those 2 songs were bops. Edited July 3 by WhateverYouWant
Chris Posted July 3 Posted July 3 Smile has Not the End of the World but everything else is pretty much disposable. At least Witness has Bigger Than Me, Bon Appetit, and Deja Vu. 2 1
skwonderfactory Posted July 3 Posted July 3 Both are VERY solid pop albums . Witness is her best to-date and Smile is a close third after Teenage Dream. You can hate Smile all you want but songs like "Never Really Over", "Cry About It Later", "Teary Eyes", "Not the End of the World", "Champagne Problems", "Tucked", "Harleys in Hawaii", "Only Love", and "What Makes a Woman" are pop perfection. 2 1
thatsmydemi Posted July 3 Posted July 3 (edited) Besides the title track, Roulette and Pendulum, nothing on Witness comes close to tracks like Cry About It Later, Teary Eyes, HIH or Never Really Over. Smile feels like a more cohesive project. Witness has, in my opinion, more skips by far. Smile > Witness. Edit: voted for Smile by mistake Edited July 3 by thatsmydemi
shyboi Posted July 3 Posted July 3 Witness is actually a very good album, never understood the need to make it pass as mid or even bad 1
Homebrand Posted July 3 Posted July 3 16 minutes ago, shyboi said: Witness is actually a very good album, never understood the need to make it pass as mid or even bad This, and it actually showed growth from her previous albums.. (still love Prism though but it was basically TD 2.0) Smile was regressive and bland compared to her other albums. Also... Witness has Power, Roulette, Save as Draft, Tsunami and the title track which are all career highlights tbh
Recommended Posts