base talk Better Discography: Beyoncé vs Tinashe

[Treason]

 

 

 

Which of these multi-talented artists has the better discography overall?

 

Beyoncé

Dangerously in Love

B'Day

I Am...Sasha Fierce

4

BEYONCÉ

Lemonade

RENAISSANCE
COWBOY CARTER

 

Tinashe

Reverie (Mixtape)

In Case We Die (Mixtape)

Black Water (Mixtape)

Amethyst (Mixtape)

Aquarius

Nightride

Joyride

Songs for You

333

BB/ANG3L

[Devin]

Dangerously in Love vs Reverie (Mixtape)

B'Day vs In Case We Die (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce vs Black Water (Mixtape)

4 vs Amethyst (Mixtape) omfg

BEYONCÉ vs Aquarius

Lemonade vs Nightride

Everything Is Love vs Joyride

The Gift vs Songs for You

RENAISSANCE vs 333 
COWBOY CARTER vs BB/ANG3L

 

7-6 

two solid discographies.

[Minto]

 

Dangerously in Love vs Reverie (Mixtape)

B'Day vs In Case We Die (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce vs Black Water (Mixtape) 

4 vs Amethyst (Mixtape)

BEYONCÉ vs Aquarius

Lemonade vs Nightride 

RENAISSANCE vs Joyride 
COWBOY CARTER vs Songs for You 

 

those nashe mixtapes are kinda duds im sorry 

 

Edited Tuesday at 02:01 PM by Minto

[ScorpiosGroove]

the one we don't have to look up on google 

[willmcclure9]

Overall Tinashe by far, Beyoncé does have ST & Ren tho 

[Pheromosa]

Bey for all 

We don't need a poll 

[prézli]

Beyoncé

[glitch]

46 minutes ago, Minto said:

those nashe mixtapes are kinda duds im sorry 

Erm Reverie and Black Water are both amazing ntm.

 

OP you got In Case We Die and Reverie the wrong way round.

 

OT: Love both but I enjoy every Tinashe album whereas there's maybe only three Bey albums that I regularly come back to

[SapphireSky]

Tinashe has amethyst and Nightride so she wins by default 

[B-Luke]

Beyoncé for all and by far.

[YoungDreamer]

Dangerously in Love vs In Case We Die (Mixtape)

B'Day vs Reverie (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce vs Black Water (Mixtape)

4 vs Amethyst (Mixtape) 

BEYONCÉ vs Aquarius 

Lemonade vs Nightride

Everything Is Love vs Joyride

The Gift vs Songs for You

RENAISSANCE vs 333 
COWBOY CARTER vs BB/ANG3L

 

Both legends

 

 

Let's not do Stunners vs Destiny's Child tho ddddddddddddddd

[Club classic]

 

Dangerously in Love vs Reverie (Mixtape)

B'Day vs In Case We Die (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce vs Black Water (Mixtape)

4 vs Amethyst (Mixtape) 

BEYONCÉ vs Aquarius 

Lemonade vs Nightride

Everything Is Love vs Joyride

The Gift vs Songs for You

RENAISSANCE vs 333 
COWBOY CARTER vs BB/ANG3L

[Ayanaa]

Tinashe 

[CityPop]

Dangerously in Love vs In Case We Die (Mixtape)

B'Day vs Reverie (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce vs Black Water (Mixtape)

4 vs Amethyst (Mixtape) 

BEYONCÉ vs Aquarius 

Lemonade vs Nightride

Everything Is Love vs Joyride

The Gift vs Songs for You

RENAISSANCE vs 333 
COWBOY CARTER vs BB/ANG3L

I love Beyonce but it's Tinashe across the board.

Edited yesterday at 01:16 AM by CityPop

[Soda Pop Queen]

I like both but Beyoncé. Her discography has and will continue to inspire many younger artists, Tinashe included. Lucky for Tinny, Beyoncé is also a fan. 

[Frappucino]

I prefer Tinashe but I'll be the first to admit that I don't think Tinashe can pull of a Renaissance or even come close to it 

[AxelFox]

Nobody that has debuted after Beyonce has a better body of work than hers. 

 

This forum can stay pretending otherwise though. 

[QuanticXplosion]

Tinashe is better than Beyonce in every possible front. Starting with the fact that she writes her music and produces it. 

[Pepo]

1 minute ago, QuanticXplosion said:

Tinashe is better than Beyonce in every possible front. Starting with the fact that she writes her music and produces it. 

The dumbest post I have ever read on atrl.

[Homebrand]

Dangerously in Love vs In Case We Die (Mixtape)

B'Day vs Reverie (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce vs Black Water (Mixtape)

4 vs Amethyst (Mixtape) 

BEYONCÉ vs Aquarius (love Aquarius though, but ST just stomps)

Lemonade vs Nightride

Everything Is Love vs Joyride

The Gift vs Songs for You

RENAISSANCE vs 333 
COWBOY CARTER vs BB/ANG3L

 

5/5... I kinda give the edge to Tinashe though. Not a single bad project there

[QuanticXplosion]

1 hour ago, Pepo said:

The dumbest post I have ever read on atrl.

Why? She doesn't have the budget to snatch Writing credit for adding commas to a grocery list or the husband to purchase a streaming platform to report fake numbers for his superstar wife and be investigated by the FBI because of it. 

Edited yesterday at 01:22 PM by QuanticXplosion

[theblackestday]

Tinashe has the best discography of all time… don't compete where you can't compare!

[needs]

Tinashe, actually.

[Batsy Armada]

Beyoncé for daytime listening, Tinashe for nighttime listening. This one made me think harder than I thought it would, honestly. Tinashe's albums are just so sublime and elegant.

[costlyxo]

Dangerously in Love VS In Case We Die (Mixtape)

B'Day VS Reverie (Mixtape)

I Am...Sasha Fierce VS Black Water (Mixtape)

4 VS Aquarius

BEYONCÉ VS Nightride (impossible)

Lemonade VS Joyride

RENAISSANCE VS Songs for You
COWBOY CARTER VS 333

 

I omitted Amethyst and BBANGEL since they're both amazing but so short. Plus I don't listen to Bey's "side" albums (The Gift and Everything is Love) so I can't compare those fairly. 

 

Tinashe is probably my favorite artist in the whole world, and one of few people who can remotely compare to Bey in terms of reinvention and commitment to her craft. Still she doesn't quite have the range. T is great and very new school. Like she excels in her lane of moody, electronic, introspective, sensual and occasionally pop with mixed results. While it's not super common Bey has also dabbled in that like in her self-titled.

 

But Tinashe could never sing songs like Deja Vú, Countdown, or Don't Hurt Yourself. Besides Bey having unreal vocals she also has that commanding old school energy, plus being truly southern she has those country and funk influences. T is a decade+ younger in literal age and career so maybe her discography will get even stronger in time. Long post but I do have to bow down to Bey here.