base talk Debut Album: Avril Lavigne vs Ashlee Simpson

[Josh]

[Trent W]

Let Go was the original thing

 

The other one was good but clearly influenced 

[dawnettakins]

Avril sweetie I'm so so sorry..

[poki]

Let Go 

 

Best debut album from the 2000s for me

[Gorjesspazze9]

Ashlee could never

[itshyolee]

Avril, but Michelle Branch low key clears both

[ThomasTea]

This disrespect to Ms Lavigne… 

[charmed23]

55 minutes ago, itshyolee said:

Avril, but Michelle Branch low key clears both

Then her second album Hotel Paper clears her debut 

[MusicLoverDude]

Love Ashlee but Avril CLEARS her on both pills. 

 

Let Go is all killer and no filler. Undiscovered has three skippable songs on it. (Surrender, Love Me For Me, Unreachable)

[AshleeSimpsonFan]

Ashlee for both 

[MattieB]

This is so ******* disrespectful to Avril, Jesus 

[Onyxmage]

"Tomorrow" alone destroys Ashlee's entire first album.  

[Iceland]

Ashlee's album except for Lala 

I love let go tho 

 

[Maroonx]

avril for sure

[KKKIMO92]

Avril definitely has one of the best debut album in history, there's no doubt

[eyeroll]

I'm convinced that anyone voting for Jessica Simpson's less rich sibling is just trolling bc there's no ******* way

[naval23]

One of the most disrespectful polls ever

 

Complicated and I'm With You alone >>>

 

Even La La doesn't touch Sk8er Boi

[LatinFreak]

I dont even care much for Avril but this thread feels disrespectful to her. 

[Johnny Jacobs]

You've lost your god damn mind. 

 

I'm with you's bridge alone clears Ashlee as a whole. 

 

Piece of me is a classic tho. 

 

It would be like comparing dopamine to dangerously in love 

[charmed23]

On 6/29/2024 at 2:14 PM, MusicLoverDude said:

Love Ashlee but Avril CLEARS her on both pills. 

 

Let Go is all killer and no filler. Undiscovered has three skippable songs on it. (Surrender, Love Me For Me, Unreachable)

Gurl, Unreachable is UNskippable! Give it another try!

[UnusualBoy]

Avril wins this one!

[Alldeezy]

I love both tbh 

[KKCuteCat]

Compare Ashlee to someone closer to her level. Might be Hilary Duff. 

[The7thStranger]

Ashlee had some cute singles, but Avril clears.

[EliMaraj]

Ashlee's debut is ICONIC in it's own right. Autobiography is actually a VERY solid piece of work.

But Let Go is one of the greatest debuts of ALL time. It's incomparable in the grand scheme of things.