Jump to content

Break The Ice Vs. Style Vs. Walking on Air Vs. Only Girl Vs. Alejandro


Brit v. Tay V. Katy V. Rih V. Gaga  

93 members have voted

  1. 1. Which pop gem is better?

    • Break The Ice
      40
    • Style
      13
    • Walking On Air
      12
    • Only Girl
      6
    • Alejandro
      22


Recommended Posts

Posted

Which mpg master class in the art of 'pop science' do you think is the best? :sistrens:

Posted

omg this is a really tough choice for me between Alejandro and Break the Ice, but I went with Break the Ice

 :jonnycat: They put crack in that song

  • Like 4
  • Thanks 1
Posted

This is the most random group of songs :deadbanana2:

  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 3
Posted (edited)

"Break the Ice" alone due to its instrumental, but, also it's just an amazing pop/dance track. "Style" follows closely behind. :gaycat:
 

"Alejandro" is fine. I mean, who wasn't singing parts of this song back in 2011? It was mildly catchy. 
 

I could never get into "Only Girl (In the World)," it sounded a year too late upon its release. "Walking On Air" did as well, but, Katy's vocals and its production saved it a bit.

Edited by Brikenbur
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

Break The Ice is my favourite Britney song ever (and I'm a stan), but the other options are amazing as well

 

Break The Ice

Style

Walking on Air (was obsessed when it came out)

Alejandro 

 

But they're all career highlights imo 

 

EDIT: Forgot Only Girl was in the list. Probably the one that aged the worst, but was an absolute banger when it came out

Edited by toy soldier.
  • Like 3
Posted

1. Alejandro

2. Only Girl

3. Break The Ice

4. Style

5. Walking On Air

Posted

Accidentally voted Only Girl

 

Alejandro is one of the best songs of all time (also my most played)

 

Posted
9 minutes ago, Mr. Stratus said:

Which mpg master class in the art of 'pop science' do you think is the best? :sistrens:

 

Posted

Break the ice, but specifically the Jason rock remix >>

  • Like 1
Posted

Walking On Air is my favorite.

Posted

I think PF or BR are better examples of "pop science master class" given their ingenious hooks/choruses, but Gaga still washes regardless :sistrens:

  • Like 1
Posted

I love all of these! Personally I'd say it's something like

 

Walking On Air > Break The Ice > Alejandro > Only Girl > Style

Posted (edited)

The way I saw "Walking on Air" and my first thought was Austria's 2017 eurovision flop- I mean song

 

It's a hard pick between Break the Ice and Alejandro... I got into BtI much more recently so ig I like it more? Alejandro still remains iconic and Only Girl is also a bop (haven't heard the Katy one I think? Or at least not in a loooong time bc I would remember)

Edited by Illyboy
Posted

voted Break The Ice cuz this exists 

 

 

  • Like 7
Posted
1 minute ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

voted Break The Ice cuz this exists 

 

 

omg I didn't know about this, it's like a cinematic version for a dark film like crime or mystery I love it

  • Thanks 1
Posted (edited)
11 minutes ago, Kayseri Mantisi said:

voted Break The Ice cuz this exists 

 

 

Didn't know this existed. I love it :heart:
My vote goes to BTI but they are all strong contenders.

Edited by ChooseyLover
  • Thanks 1
Posted
6 minutes ago, frankvert said:

I think PF or BR are better examples of "pop science master class" given their ingenious hooks/choruses, but Gaga still washes regardless :sistrens:

Neither of those are better than Alejandro. Only Paparazzi is a better example of "pop science master class"

 

OT: Only Girl > Break The Ice > Alejandro > Style > Walking on Air (never understood the appeal for this song, Katy has so many better songs)

Posted

1. Alejandro 

2. Break The Ice

3. Only Girl

4 Style

5. Walking On Air 

Posted

"Break The Ice" > "Style" > "Alejandro" > "Only Girl" > "Walking On Air".   

I still don't understand why people like "Walking On Air" that much.   :biblio:

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Alejandro > Only Girl > Break The Ice > Walking On Air > Style

Posted

1. Walking On Air

2. Break The Ice

3. Alejandro

4. Style

5. Only Girl (In The World)

 

But all of them are 10/10.

Posted

They're all kinda great. 

Posted

Nothing touches Break The Ice, Style comes close though

  • Like 1
Posted
48 minutes ago, xXavril said:

Break the ice, but specifically the Jason rock remix >>

I wish this were on Spotify. 

Posted

It's a toss up for BTI & Style but they're all amazing song.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.