base talk ...Baby One More Time vs Heartbreaker vs Genie In a Bottle vs If You Had My Love

[Josh]

[Migs]

 

A cultural reset.

[All Guns Blazing]

1. BOMT

2. Heartbreaker

3. BOMT

[bielneira]

"...Baby One More Time" for all!

[PMKARDASHIAN]

BOMT barely beats out Heartbreaker but BOMT for all 

[Doctor Dick]

Britney looking like a child on that single artwork while Christina who's about the same age looks like a 20+ year old 

 

OT: I love Heartbreaker the most but BOMT is the biggest one. 

Edited Thursday at 12:37 AM by Doctor Dick

[LatinFreak]

Mariah. Mariah. Brit. 

[Sharamee6]

Genie in every single way. 

[Sharamee6]

1 hour ago, Doctor Dick said:

Britney looking like a child on that single artwork while Christina who's about the same age looks like a 20+ year old 

 

OT: I love Heartbreaker the most but BOMT is the biggest one. 

Funny that Xtina still looks 20 today... while the others 

 

Anyway.. Back to Genie 🧞‍♂️

[JanEgo]

Baby One More Time is one of the most earth shattering debuts ever and iconic to this day, this poll is not even a contest.

 

but it feels like such an anomaly in her otherwise sonically different and often lackluster career (with sporadic moments of greatness). You can tell it wasn't written for her but it was really a lightning in a bottle moment.

[shyboi]

1 hour ago, Doctor Dick said:

Britney looking like a child on that single artwork while Christina who's about the same age looks like a 20+ year old 

 

OT: I love Heartbreaker the most but BOMT is the biggest one. 

 

Christina A. is way older than Britney 

 

 

OT. BOMT 

[Doctor Dick]

4 minutes ago, shyboi said:

 

Christina A. is way older than Britney 

 

 

OT. BOMT 

She was 18-19 when she released her debut, Britney was 17 

[Trent W]

BOMT is like the most iconic and best pop track all time next to Thriller

 

Those are classics of the classics

 

Sorry but the others don't compete

[futuresuperstar2023]

2 hours ago, shyboi said:

 

Christina A. is way older than Britney 

 

 

OT. BOMT 

Christina was born December 18, 1980. Britney was born December 2, 1981. I'm not seeing the way older

[J Legend X]

well.. Genie is the only one that still sounds fresh, but of course that wasn't part of the poll...

[Phaunzie]

LS Genie (The best song of the list that has aged far better than the rest, only Heartbreaker is up there, BOMT aged the worst)

MV Heartbreaker or IIHYL, IIHYL win still. (The Video predicted live streaming, and online parasocial relationships and is far better to look at than teeny boppers on a beach gyrating , underage girls in school shaking their kitty during the third period , and whatever imposter kink play/revenge fantasy Mariah had going on ).

 

Shameful honestly.

Choreo BOMT.

 

 

Edited Thursday at 03:14 AM by Phaunzie

[CocoPouf]

1. Genie 2. BOMT 3. BOMT

[Buffy]

How are you not going to include Jessica's lead single I Wanna Love You Forever? The only one out of these girls who actually debuted vocals.

 

 

 

 

[Josh]

1 minute ago, Buffy said:

How are you not going to include Jessica's lead single I Wanna Love You Forever? The only one out of these girls who actually debuted vocals.

 

 

 

 

She wasn't serving choreography

[dopamina]

Genie

Bomt

Bomt

[Buffy]

Just now, Josh said:

She wasn't serving choreography

Fair enough. It's probably best those performances stay locked in a vault. They tried to make her into Britney 2.0 and it didn't work. Great vocals, beautiful vocals though 

[Avenger]

Bomt for all. 

[AxelFox]

Heartbreaker > BOMT > IYHML > GIAB for me

 

All amazing though! God music used to be so great. 

[Cardcaptor Sakura]

Genie was the song of the summer 

[JoAddams]

Heartbreaker > IYHML > GIAB > BOMT