base talk Let Go vs Under My Skin vs The Best Damn Thing: rank them!

[Da Vinci]

Crazy how Avril (?) served 3 iconic pop-rock albums back to back to back before the age of 23!

 

 

And each one is distinctive from each other and represents the stage/era of 2000s pop-rock/pop-punk they were released in.

 

My ranking:

 

1. Let Go - has the highest highs but the lowest lows with the last 3 tracks lowkey being fillers, would've been perfect as a 10-track album

2. Under My Skin - no fillers, better production, better vocals but also lacks the higher highs of Let Go so it's #2 for me though it's really close, MHE is the weakest track especially lyrically IMO

3. The Best Damn Thing - not as cohesive as the other 2 with random slow piano ballads that derail and drain the energy of the experience, also has the least depth out of all 3 and the fun, campy, bratty, villainous mean girl persona becomes really grating when you're not in the mood for it anymore 

[aotwbys]

Let Go > The Best Damn Thing > Under My Skin

[Raphy23]

1. Under My Skin

2. Let Go

3. TBDT

 

All iconic

[Gorjesspazze9]

Let Go first 3 songs is probably the greatest opening ever  Like How tf did she do this as a teen?! 
Under My Skin production and songwriting got even stronger. TBDT was my coming of age album too. So it's hard to choose. 

[selena_lavigne]

The way she got better and better with her first 4 albums. Legendary behavior. 

[xXavril]

Probably a wildly unpopular opinion but 

 

TBDT>UMS>LG

[jonapova]

Let Go - Under my skin ————> TBDT
 

Her first 2 albums were amazing and my favourite often changes. 
 

Also I do not accept the slander for Naked!

 

 

[JoAddams]

[KKKIMO92]

UMS>TBDT>LG. This is simply because TBDT is my first Avril album. But Let go is the goal, the themes, melodies and lyrics are just impeccable.

[SlowGinFizzzz]

Under My Skin

Let Go

The Best Damn Thing

 

 

[Da Vinci]

1 hour ago, Gorjesspazze9 said:

Let Go first 3 songs is probably the greatest opening ever  Like How tf did she do this as a teen?! 

*first 4 songs including I'm With God!

[MetropoliMusical]

Under My Skin

Let Go

The Best Damn Thing

 

 

 

[Movimento Perpétuo]

UMS >>> Let Go >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> TBDT

[G.U.Y_Del_Rey]

My ranking is the release order.

[butterflymimi]

let go > tbdt > ums 

 

they're all great though. ums has the highest highs for me with fall to pieces, my happy ending, nobody's home but i'm more fond of the other two as a whole

[Prince George]

Let Go >= Under My Skin >> TBDT