base talk Speak Now vs THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT

[Diesel is Desire]

 

 

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

[YellowRibbon]

Mine vs Fortnight

 

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

 

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

 

Speak Now vs Down Bad

 

Dear John vs So Long, London

 

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

 

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

 

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

 

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

 

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

 

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

 

Haunted vs loml

 

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

 

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

 

Ours vs The Alchemy

 

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

 

Superman vs The Black Dog

 

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

 

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

 

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

 

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

 

Foolish One vs So High School

 

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

[Diesel is Desire]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

Why did Speak Now clear?

[M!X]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

 

 

This system makes it seems like TTPD gagged SN for me but I would say the standard version of Speak Now is actually better than TTPD, idk

[Loca]

Speak Now because at least I managed to finish it

[EnigmaticAndroid]

Preach Now... sweetie 

[Pheromosa]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

Super biased to Speak Now TV, it is what it is

[ariananext]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

Speak Now is my third favourite Taylor album, TTPD is far from my favourite, but I'm not familiar with Taylor's vault tracks (other than ICSY), honestly most of them didn't click with me so that kinda gave TTPD the edge, but I like Speak Now much more as an album, as it's the first Taylor album I heard and loved. TTPD isn't bad though, I just think many tracks are unnecessary and blend sonically. 

Edited June 5 by ariananext

[RihannaLoverrr]

 

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

 

[SmashingMiley]

Speak Now (Taylor's Version) is my favorite Taylor's album. Meanwhile TTPD ranks 4th/5th for me. 
 

Speak Now >> Red >> 1989 >> TTPD/Folkmore

[Mephisto]

Speak Now is her best album. TTPD is one of her worst.

[gagacasanova]

Speak now >>>

[jomarr]

The Tortured Tympanic Membrane remains one of her worst albums whereas Jesus Now is her best album.

[aotearoa]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

[Achilles.]

Mine vs Fortnight vs The Black Dog

Sparks Fly vs Tortured Poets Department vs imgonnagetyouback

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys vs The Albatross

Speak Now vs Down Bad vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Dear John vs So Long London vs How Did It End

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him vs So High School

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out The Slammer vs I Hate It Here

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!! vs Thank You Aimee

Enchanted vs Guilty As Sin vs I Look in People's Windows

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me vs The Prophecy

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him vs Cassandra

Haunted vs loml vs Peter

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It With A Broken Heart vs The Bolter

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived vs Robin

Ours vs The Alchemy vs The Manuscript

If This Was A Movie vs Clara Bow

 

Speak Now: 7

The Anthology: 6

Tortured Poets: 3

 

Mine vs The Black Dog was a toss up but I threw it to the former for history's sake. Tortured Poets only got one of its three points due to ICFH's weak competition…

[UnusualBoy]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

Overall, I like SN better but the vault tracks kind of dragged down so that basically gives TTPD a bit of an edge over it.

[pavi]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad 

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived 

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

[TaylenaStan]

PEAK NOW ofc
I wont post my track by track comparison as i might be seen as an Obsessed TTPD Hater 

[RoyalT]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

 

Speak Now it is!

[Buffy]

Ouch… Speak Now is better. These threads expose the better albums in her discography when it's all said and done 

[Safe&Sound]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

SPEAK NOW - 12

TTPD - 11

[Sad Serenade]

Speak Now is one of Taylor's best album.

[Gladiator]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

Speak Now: 13

Tortured Poets Department: 10

 

WHERE WAS THE BOLTER IN THIS LIST ITS THE BEST SONG ON THE ALBUM

Edited June 5 by Gladiator

[Lorenzo22]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

Speak Now: 9

TTPD: 14

[G.U.Y_Del_Rey]

Mine vs Fortnight

Sparks Fly vs The Tortured Poets Department

Back to December vs My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys

Speak Now vs Down Bad

Dear John vs So Long, London

Mean vs But Daddy I Love Him

The Story of Us vs Fresh Out the Slammer

Never Grow Up vs Florida!!!

Enchanted vs Guilty as Sin?

Better Than Revenge vs Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?

Innocent vs I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)

Haunted vs loml

Last Kiss vs I Can Do It with a Broken Heart

Long Live vs The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

Ours vs The Alchemy

If This Was a Movie vs Clara Bow

Superman vs The Black Dog

Electric Touch vs imgonnagetyouback

When Emma Falls in Love vs The Albatross

I Can See You vs Chloe or Sam or Sophia or Marcus

Castles Crumbling vs How Did It End?

Foolish One vs So High School

Timeless vs I Hate It Here

 

13 vs 10