celeb news Miley on Bey collab: "I wrote that song two and a half years ago"

[shyboi]

You can tell Miley was itching to let the world know about this

 

clever because it comes as very casual and not shady and at the same time she's making sure the message is clear enough 

Edited June 3 by shyboi

[Daglazzo]

Just now, shyboi said:

You can tell Miley was itching to let the world know about this, clever because it comes as very casual and not shady and the same time she's making sure the message is clear enough 

As she should. She wrote the song, not Beyoncé who took the credit. Facts are facts.

[PrettyHurts]

22 minutes ago, Badgalbriel said:

Considering the song's melody is exactly the same as the demo, shouldn't the supposedly new arrangement be counted as a production credit, though? This is an honest question and my intention is not to shade Beyonce. 

Why don't you ask Miley, Bey and the several other people credited with the songs writing and production how they came up with the credits? Who is credited as a writer and producer can be complicated when there's many people involved. 

[Pinkbutterflies]

5 minutes ago, kimberly said:

whatever you say, writing expert!

Maybe you could give Beyonce a writing lesson too?

[on the line]

43 minutes ago, kimberly said:

Beyoncé haters forever failing to understand that "writing credits" don't mean putting pen to paper and opening thesaurus.com 

 

even if she were to, let's say, keep the original lyrics as they were, Beyoncé's melodic additions and arrangement are also considered songwriting.

Are Beyonce's melodic additions and arrangements in the room with you right now too?

[family.guy123]

The Song of the Year GRAMMY award winner will surely be bothered by this 

[liquiddiamonds]

Miley basically saying it was a dream come true and y'all scrambling for shade lol 

[Kill Me]

Not the beyhive trying to justify this theft by saying adlibs count as writing credits... lmao.

People don't even give credit to string arrangers despite them adding much more to the melody of the song than harmonised vocals in a different key.

[LosingHimWasBlue]

Shameless and embarrassing 

[AmericanIdol]

Oh wow, Beyonce strikes again with her stealing credits tactics.

[Shimenawa]

So Miley wrote the entire song?

 

Why is Beyoncé recording Miley leftovers from 2 years ago and why is her name in the credits

 

Edited June 3 by Shimenawa

[Beyoncei]

22 minutes ago, Daglazzo said:

As she should. She wrote the song, not Beyoncé who took the credit. Facts are facts.

Y'all just love to latch! Any opportunity. Anyway who says Beyoncéi and I wrote a song. She was simply highlighting her input. Next…

[Cleanromantic]

This comes off as very shady ngl . You can tell that Miley was waiting to share that info, cause I remember the hive saying the opposite when the song came out.

[Tusk]

34 minutes ago, Pinkbutterflies said:

Oh pls. Just because you added a few extra notes from the original, doesn't entitle you a writing credit. When you have to resort to doing ad-libs as a case for beys writing validity, you know this whole thing I a joke .

Agreed.  Stevie Nicks never put herself as a songwriter for these types of instances.

 

She is credited on Seven Wonders as "additional lyrics by…" and not as the writer of the song.  She changed a few words and ad libbed. That's how it should be credited.

[JEWRJEWR]

not beyonce inviting miley to her own song  

[Joaco95]

1 hour ago, ImpressMeMuch said:

not beyonce "inviting" miley to sing on her own song

well yes

she could have bought the song off ryan tedder without a miley collab, but you all just like to act dumb when it comes to Beyoncé

[Darkgalord]

[Riot]

I'll be an ad-lib songwriter

'Till the day I die

[KingWitch]

Why do all these people always say "I wrote this song" and not "Beyonce and I wrote that song" ? Can't they at least acknowledge her part in writing the song ?

[IsidoraMarí]

8 minutes ago, Riot said:

I'll be an ad-lib songwriter

'Till the day I die

I don't know much bout algeba

But I know four plus one is five

[ImpressMeMuch]

17 minutes ago, Joaco95 said:

well yes

she could have bought the song off ryan tedder without a miley collab, but you all just like to act dumb when it comes to Beyoncé

That doesn't make it less funny 

[Summerboy95]

1 hour ago, kimberly said:

Beyoncé haters forever failing to understand that "writing credits" don't mean putting pen to paper and opening thesaurus.com 

 

even if she were to, let's say, keep the original lyrics as they were, Beyoncé's melodic additions and arrangement are also considered songwriting.

If someone conducts scientific research and documents it through a scientific paper, adding correct punctuation and APA citations doesn't make it mine or ours. 

 

Same applies here 

 

----

 

OT: Not surprised! Miley is an amazing and talented artist and performer

Edited June 3 by Summerboy95

[Joaco95]

1 minute ago, ImpressMeMuch said:

That doesn't make it less funny 

it is funnyt tho

 

can the useless mods close this thread before it gets full hate like those ts threads? ty

[Simple]

I bet Beyonce is not happy about this interview, no more grammys for Miley 

 

[ImpressMeMuch]

12 minutes ago, Joaco95 said:

it is funnyt tho

 

can the useless mods close this thread before it gets full hate like those ts threads? ty

It's a funny turn of events. I laughed and moved on and you should too. 
 

The mods are great at their job, sorry you're mad.