Brooklyn Baby Posted May 22 Posted May 22 GUTS - 91 COWBOY CARTER - 91 HIT ME HARD AND SOFT - 88 eternal sunshine - 84 THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT - 76 Radical Optimism - 73 Did the critics spill? Are GUTS and COWBOY CARTER the two best MPG albums released in the past year?
Popular Post WildAmerican Posted May 22 Popular Post Posted May 22 you need a stan phd to comprehend that thread title 21
alexrex Posted May 22 Posted May 22 GUTS yuh, very deserved CC Is more of a 80 album, plus it wasn't written by the main artist 4 10
Donquizote Posted May 22 Posted May 22 CC is a horrible album and has no replay value. GP agree and it's dropping like rock on spotify. Critics are biased because it's beyonce GUTS is a good album and deserved its flower 4 13
UnusualBoy Posted May 22 Posted May 22 (edited) Guts should not be in the 90s when it's basically a watered down version of Sour. No matter how many downvotes I get from the little olives... Edited May 22 by UnusualBoy 5 7
Brikenbur Posted May 22 Posted May 22 4 minutes ago, Danes said: 88 & 84 are excellent scores too though. What about 76? 1
Brikenbur Posted May 22 Posted May 22 1 minute ago, Donquizote said: CC is a horrible album and has no replay value. GP agree and it's dropping like rock on spotify. Critics are biased because it's beyonce GUTS is a good album and deserved its flower Imagine having these ear drums 1
Obsession Posted May 22 Posted May 22 4 minutes ago, alexrex said: GUTS yuh, very deserved CC Is more of a 80 album, plus it wasn't written by the main artist Beyoncé has writing credits but even so, writing your own album doesn't make it good, and neither does the inverse. It was not even a standard thing until like very recently. 6
45seconds Posted May 22 Posted May 22 4 minutes ago, alexrex said: GUTS yuh, very deserved CC Is more of a 80 album, plus it wasn't written by the main artist When are y'all gonna give up this "written by" narrative?
KatyPrismSpirit Posted May 22 Posted May 22 9 minutes ago, WildAmerican said: you need a stan phd to comprehend that thread title why did this make me laugh but guts & cowboy carter are better than all those albums so critics spilled!
Mr. Duff Posted May 22 Posted May 22 I like CC but I don't think it's that good of an album to warrant a 91. I do agree with GUTS, excellent album. I think HMHAS got a fair score, perfectly within the 80s range. Eternal Sunshine, I probably will get flack on this but while I think it's a great pop record, I just don't feel any connection to it. It's just there, a great pop record. I would probably switch its score with TTPD. If you get TTPD, you get it. I guess you can say that about my opinion with ES though, and unfortunately I just don't get it. Radical Optimism is pretty bland aside from the first two singles and Happy for You. Surprised it got a 73. 1
Donquizote Posted May 22 Posted May 22 4 minutes ago, Brikenbur said: Imagine having these ear drums Glad GP and me have normal ear drums OT: Hit Me Hard and Soft should score >95. P4K tried to be edgy and gave her low score 1 2
Rama Posted May 22 Posted May 22 The inflation Realistically: GUTS: 78 CC: 82 HMHAS: 78 ES: 75 TTPD: 72 RO: 70 1 2
By the Water Posted May 22 Posted May 22 If only that translated into interest from the public I'm sure that metacritic score will look great on Olivia's shelf though 1
Souvenir Posted May 22 Posted May 22 How is CC that high? one of the worst albums of all time. but yeah they spilled with GUTS 3 9
Pheromosa Posted May 22 Posted May 22 GUTS is a little high but i agree with the ranking I guess. I'd put TTPD over RO though
Delicate Posted May 22 Posted May 22 You guys care more about critics than your own taste Like Guts is cute, but no one will ever convince me that these Sour rejects are better than ES or HMHAS 1
alexrex Posted May 22 Posted May 22 14 minutes ago, 45seconds said: When are y'all gonna give up this "written by" narrative? It's been known for a while Ms Carter-Knowles likes to take more credit than deserved. No wonder she has yet to win AOTY. 2 1
Both Sides Now Posted May 22 Posted May 22 I do think that GUTS is a little high. I enjoyed it, but I don't think it's better than Billie's or Ariana's.
teenager Posted May 22 Posted May 22 (edited) They should all be lower apart from maybe Billies album. ES, RO and TTPD should be all be in the high 60 to low 70s Edited May 22 by teenager 2
Recommended Posts