base talk The Tortured Poets Department Review Thread | MC - 76

[wantedyoutogrow]

if only she can be as acclaimed as PinkGodtheress

"Heaven Knows" is in stores everywhere you guys!

 

[Moloko Plus]

1 minute ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Thats a beautiful picture of an artist that constantly evolves and releases QUA-LI-TY. Its great to look at one of that calibre, right? I agree

 

Incorrect, it's another artist that is similar to "the MCU. While they both clearly boost the industry in terms of revenue, they completely derive it from quality and creativity". 

 

Like not the Beyoncé stans coming for Taylor talking about creativity and originality 

[WeFoundWill]

1 minute ago, Burn said:

Is this real? It's still showing as 77 to me.

It was real but somehow the 0.5 got removed

 

 

[Machete]

Who would've thought Taylor Swift would be the one to end the poptimism era 

[Feanor]

17 minutes ago, duybeeGAshantiGA said:

She almost got hit with Lover. But she revived everything with folklore. That does not mean she is immune. Well we can only wait and see.

She was the best-selling artist in the world in 2019 thanks to 'Lover'.

 

OT: Not 100+ members browsing. Who knew Taylor would become the most divisive artist on ATRL.

[Moloko Plus]

5 minutes ago, Burn said:

The most influential producer of our time who most certainly influenced a majority of the creative team behind Renaissance! 

[Sugden]

3 minutes ago, Burn said:

Is this real? It's still showing as 77 to me.

very much real

[FolkLover1989]

1 minute ago, Machete said:

Who would've thought Taylor Swift would be the one to end the poptimism era 

????

 

You all be saying anything now

 

[Sadie Saxton]

2 minutes ago, MonsterConnor said:

77 for regular version, 69 for anthology version. Can't wait for the threads being ridiculous and asking: "Is TTPD Taylor's Witness era" or some ****. 

I think one's been made already asking if it's her ARTPOP 

[FolkLover1989]

So atrl said Taylor is vanilla and no one cares about her

 

But what I see is , Taylor has the most discussed and biggest album of the year that is extremely divisive 

 

So in reality , Taylor won 

[Kern]

5 minutes ago, WeFoundWill said:

It's very clear what is happening here tho, whilst "objective' music criticism never existed in the first place, It's obviously those publications want the clicks and they know they'll get those with either a 1 or 10 star review

 

kinda funny how this hasn't clicked for many ppl in here. these publications operate like stan twitter. 

Please grow up  those are grown ass people writing those reviews, enough with the stupid conspiracy theories. 

[Burn]

someone make a version like this but with TTDP's scores instead of Solar Power's

 

 

Spoiler

 

[Kristie Kuwa]

4 minutes ago, Moloko Plus said:

Incorrect, it's another artist that is similar to "the MCU. While they both clearly boost the industry in terms of revenue, they completely derive it from quality and creativity". 

 

Like not the Beyoncé stans coming for Taylor talking about creativity and originality 

U know, Bey has written great songs in the past such as Independent Woman, but could Taylor sing American Requiem or Daughter off of Beys newest Album?

 

 

 

Ps: That was a rhetorical question

 

Edited April 22 by Kristie Kuwa

[WeFoundWill]

1 minute ago, Kern said:

Please grow up  those are grown ass people writing those reviews, enough with the stupid conspiracy theories. 

 

Imagine believing this album is deserving of either a 1 or 10 out of 10

[Gerardo]

people are doing too much 

it's mid but is the definition of a 6/10, I've only listened to the standard and it was meh, at least the 0.5 stars review will balance out the kiss-ass reviews she got from RS and others 

Edited April 22 by Gerardo

[Lovett]

7 minutes ago, Burn said:

Is this real? It's still showing as 77 to me.

5 minutes ago, WeFoundWill said:

It was real but somehow the 0.5 got removed

 

There are two Metacritic pages. One for the standard album (currently 77) and one for the anthology album (currently 69).

[Komet]

Ok but 77 for a record that includes something like But Fuhrer I Love Him is a great score

 

[Rotunda]

3 minutes ago, Moloko Plus said:

Incorrect, it's another artist that is similar to "the MCU. While they both clearly boost the industry in terms of revenue, they completely derive it from quality and creativity". 

 

Like not the Beyoncé stans coming for Taylor talking about creativity and originality 

You know how people (both Swifties and non-Swifties) are highly critical of Jack Antonoff's work? 
 

Even if we want to assume Bey had 0% to do with CC or Ren aside from providing vocals, I've never heard any of y'all make the case that any of the actual contributors to her albums did a bad job. 
 

Y'all pretend like Bey doesn't contribute to her art, but if that's the case, y'all would be calling out her contributors for creating bad art. But y'all don't do that…

[KingJay]

Damn last time I checked this was at 90

[cuteboyzay]

Idk why but I feel SO BAD! 

[satellites.™]

1 hour ago, chosensparkles said:

poor Taylor, she can cry in her millions while chronically online haters keep hating

Your signature tells us you care, and ALL the pop girls are rich so this post is irrelevant anyway.

[Virgos Groove]

 

Brazillians always have the best GIFs

 

Spoiler

Translation for those who don't speak Portuguese:

 

EXTRA, EXTRA! Your 5-star score for TTPD is worth a quote and engagement

Ayy, Pitchfork, look here, take advantage of blondie's special sale

DAMMIT!

ENJOY, COSTUMER! Take an album and get 15 bonus tracks

 

[JennyWayne]

Lower Metacritic score than Chromatica currently

 

[sunbathinganimal]

1 minute ago, JennyWayne said:

Lower Metacritic score than Chromatica currently

 

well it's a worse album

 

[Illuminati]

Sputnik has 3 staff reviews for TTPD do they all count? How does it work?