base talk Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel vs I Am Sasha Fierce

[Josh]

Edited March 29 by Josh

[xrosup]

Moomoirs for both

[Laura Palmer]

*an Imperfect Angel 

[Kiss It Better]

Memoirs won for The Impossible alone, then also Candy Bling, It's A Wrap, More Than Just Friends, etc while IASF is full of fillers and skips

 

singles wise however, IASF won cause the singles from Memoirs mostly suck

[wowsignal14]

what kind if question is that.... obviously iasf

[TitanicSurvivor]

Sasha by far. So many gems mostly in the I Am... part. Mariah stopped exciting me with her music after E=MC2 (which is great imo)

[Brikenbur]

Obvi LOVE Bey, but Memoirs is such a great R&B album. I Am… is just not Bey's best work 

[I Melt Away]

Memoirs for album, IASF for singles.

(IASF remains my least favorite album from B )

[suburbannature]

Memoirs aged much better than I expected it to. It's had three songs go mega viral on Tiktok. Obsessed, It's a Wrap, and now Up Out My Face

 

 

[Saddy]

Memoirs and Memoirs

[Maroonx]

bey x

[stevyy]

The Up Out My Face album. 

[MatiRod]

"Obsessed" is a huge bop and there are some really solid tracks on Memoirs like "H.A.T.E.U.", "Candy Bling", "More Than Just Friends".

 

But IASF has generational smashes. "Single Ladies" is one of the all-time great pop songs. "Halo" one of the great pop ballads.

[Devin]

where is the neither option?  

[Nippy'sReceipts]

Memoirs is the better album.

 

IASF had the better singles