poll Better Spotify top 10: Madonna vs. Mariah

[HardBambi]

Which one has a better quality top 10?

 

 

Madonna's Spotify top 10

01 (=): Popular - 679,592,134 (+2,165,516) +1.69% {-6.95%} 
02 (=): Hung Up² - 434,628,579 (+406,470) +14.39%{+2.96%} 
03 (=): La Isla Bonita² - 366,371,605 (+353,560) +9.59% {+1.73%} *New ALL-TIME peak*
04 (=): Material Girl³ - 482,424,747 (+322,701) +4.31% {-4.00%} 
05 (=): 4 Minutes² - 349,748,347 (+284,980) +2.32% {+0.35%} 
06 (=): Like a Prayer³ - 435,723,459 (+277,985) +9.62% {-1.77%} 
07 (=): Like A Virgin² - 320,673,672 (+181,324) +4.90% {-8.27%} 
08 (=): Vogue³ - 249,978,293 (+140,168) +6.29% {+1.31%} 
09 (=): Frozen (Sickick Remix) - 163,565,585 (+119,334) +4.88% {+0.33%} *2024 peak*
10 (=): Crazy for You - 127,179,109 (+108,262) -1.37% {-0.51%} 

 

Mariah's Spotify top 10

01 - 381,362,146 - +441,183 - 1995 - Fantasy
02 - 582,177,893 - +439,256 - 2005 - We Belong Together
03 - 365,744,372 - +399,515 - 2009 - Obsessed
04 - 354,901,242 - +230,977 - 2003 - I Know what you Want
05 - 17,268,399 - +229,558 - 2024 - Yes, And? Remix
06 - 214,740,872 - +196,569 - 2008 - Touch my Body
07 - 371,888,656 - +168,277 - 1996 - Always be my Baby
08 - 245,373,252 - +125,563 - 1994 - Without You
09 - 263,568,210 - +112,521 - 1993 - Hero
10 - 185,584,550 - +98,336 - 1995 - One Sweet Day

Edited March 24 by HardBambi
Added question

[Devin]

mariah for me.

[Gladiator]

Madonna for me but I'm not into Mariah. 

[Funnyfatty]

Mariah has 3 songs above 400.000?  

I'm in shock. Fantasy being #1 is also shocking. 
 

Mariah for me though >>> 

[UrMom]

Both are flawless!

 

Gonna have to say Madge though, a bit more variety to those ten.

[Diesel is Desire]

Out of these 20 songs, Madonna 

[Material Girl]

mariah easily

[Janet]

Crazy For You that high looks weird af

[Odette Violet]

I love vocals so Mariah 

[endless_sorrow]

It's Mariah for me

[magazine]

oof, neither 

 

OT: I guess it would have to be madonna

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Mariah ate

[Lament]

I'm so mad at Madonna's top 10 being ruined by Frozen (Sickick.) It's so bad. Same for yes, and? being in Mariah's.

Both top 10 are pretty amazing and legendary though.

[blown away]

Madonna, Mariah's last three ruined it for me.

[Ck.cR]

Madonna ate and left no crumbs. 

[rebeltwat]

The one with the better discography

[Into The Void]

Honestly. About even for me

[stevyy]

Both tables in the OP were taken from UKMIX. I think it needed to be said. 

 

I provided the numbers for Mariah Carey. (as tracked daily in the Mariah Carey charts thread on UKMIX). <3

 

[stevyy]

I voted for Mariah because Fantasy happens to be the greatest song of the 1990s. <3

 

I find Frozen (sickick) not top 10 worthy in Madonna's top 10. 

 

As for Mariah, I would love to see Shake It Off and My All enter her top 10 in the future.

 

 

[Nightingale]

Both. Maybe Mariah wins by a bit

[SleepNoMore]

It's Madonna. She the queen 

[sasashite]

Madonna easily

[MadOnHer]

Like A Prayer alone clinches it for Madonna!

[HardBambi]

21 hours ago, Janet said:

Crazy For You that high looks weird af

I like it! But yeah top 15 contains Into the groove and Papa don't preach which would be much better for a number 10