poll Honey vs. Butterfly vs. Breakdown vs. The Roof vs. My All

[Saddy]

 

 

 

[Sailor Moon]

The qualiTy!

 

flawless singles run

[Galaxy]

Honey, Breakdown and The Roof are literally her 3 best songs

[playboi]

Breakdown > The Roof > Honey > Butterfly > My All

 

for MV: The Roof > Breakdown > Honey > My All > Butterfly

[rebeltwat]

These flawless singles. My personal preference is as follows:

 

The Roof

Breakdown

My All

Honey

Butterfly

[Klein]

The Roof is by far Mariah's best song and honestly one of the best song of all time. 

[Havoc]

Breakdown is Mariahs best song.

[AxelFox]

Literally each one if these is a masterpiece

 

The fact that they make up the first half of the album too... insane

 

And then there's people that try to claim Butterfly is not up there with the best female albums in recent history

[umich]

Breakdown clears. She and Bone Thugs made several points.

[blown away]

Not a single miss in this run.

 

Butterfly > (My All/Stay Awhile >) Honey > Breakdown > My All > The Roof

[moondust]

Love all these songs but Honey easily wins both.

[Havoc]

15 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

Literally each one if these is a masterpiece

 

The fact that they make up the first half of the album too... insane

 

And then there's people that try to claim Butterfly is not up there with the best female albums in recent history

It really is. One of the few albums that has both otherwordly lyrics and vocals. 

[Legend E]

Oh the quality...

 

Song-wise: The Roof > Honey > Breakdown > Butterfly > My All

Video-wise: Breakdown > Honey > My All > The Roof > Butterfly

[Doogle]

And if I said Breakdown  

[Princess Aurora]

My All and Honey 

[Kiss It Better]

song: The Roof

video: Breakdown (but i voted The Roof cause i didn't see it nnnn)

[Mitsouko]

Quote

Honey vs. Butterfly vs. Breakdown vs. The Roof vs. My All

 

For the songs, the above order exactly

For the videos, well…

[naval23]

Breakdown is God tier and My All and The Roof is A+ tier 

Edited March 17 by naval23

[yekim]

Honey the iconic bop that you are

[Mandalay]

Voted 'The Roof' for both but it's tough, like tough-tough. I just wanna point out that her vocal delivery in Butterfly and My All are impossible to imitate by anyone.

[iHype.]

Can’t choose between Honey, Butterfly, and Breakdown. All 10/10s… 

[HardBambi]

What a fantastic poll it’s hard to choose

 

Honey

My All

The Roof

B&B equal

[PMKARDASHIAN]

Breakdown and My All are at the top of her discography regardless. 
I’ve recently come around to Honey 

 

Havent heard the other two but I already know they aren’t as good as Breakdown and My All 

[suburbannature]

These masterpieces.

 

all of the videos in this era were among the best female pop artists were putting out too. This and Emancipation definitely were her best visual eras. 
 

I think Breakdown is the best video followed by Honey and The Roof. My All is stunning as well. 

[modeblock]

It's 10s across the board, but Breakdown and The Roof are just beyonddd