Jump to content
Login issues ×
Reminder of "viral" thresholds

Better first thirteen #1 singles: Beyoncé vs Rihanna

burninredhot

burninredhot
in Base

 Share

Vote!!  

92 members have voted

  1. 1. Better first thirteen #1 singles?


Recommended Posts

burninredhot Mentor

burninredhot

Posted
Posted

Both ladies have the best catalog of #1 singles among their peers, which ones do you prefer?

 

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 59
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Comedor

    2

  • Khal

    2

  • Dante

    2

  • burninredhot

    2

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

kexin Rising Star

kexin

Posted
Posted

rihanna had the better #1’s not even close

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Selegend Veteran

Selegend

Posted
Posted (edited)

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life (i love live your life, but not comparable)

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie (i love check on it, but not comparable)

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name? (i love what's my name, but not comparable)

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M (both trash)

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

 

5 x 10

easy Rih win 

Edited by Selegend
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
airplane Grand Master

airplane

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Khal Veteran

Khal

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dekkan Proficient

Dekkan

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

 

I am super happy for Bey regardless, and extremely impressed with Texas smashing. That being said, her #1 catalogue would look so much better without the remixes (no shade). Perfect Duet's spot belonged to Formation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
PrettyHurts Veteran

PrettyHurts

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella :jonny5:

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy :jonny5:

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

 

Rihanna has more of her best songs as #1s 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
BionicWooHoo Mentor

BionicWooHoo

Posted
Posted

Huh? I thought Texas hold em debuted at number 2? Or are we talking like WW or ??

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Khal Veteran

Khal

Posted
Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, BionicWooHoo said:

Huh? I thought Texas hold em debuted at number 2? Or are we talking like WW or ??

Yes, songs have debuts, then after that is something known as a 2nd week, which Texas Hold Em is #1.

Edited by Khal
  • Haha 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Shinning Veteran

Shinning

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella (sooooooo hard :weeps:)

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds (veryyy hard too)

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
State of Grace. Grand Master

State of Grace.

Posted
Posted

Rihanna's. She has the better hits overall because most of her best songs were singles.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dekkan Proficient

Dekkan

Posted
Posted
17 minutes ago, PrettyHurts said:

Rihanna has more of her best songs as #1s 

Perfectly said.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Diesel is Desire Grand Master

Diesel is Desire

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take a Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy in Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check on It vs Love the Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In the World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Rotunda Grand Master

Rotunda

Posted
Posted

If I compare them chronologically I think Bey wins more match-ups for me, but if I rate them all, I think Rih has the higher average.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Squall Grand Master

Squall

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take a Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy in Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check on It vs Love the Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In the World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jdanton2 Mentor

jdanton2

Posted
Posted

8 Rihanna vs 5 Beyonce

 

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Gov Hooka Mentor

Gov Hooka

Posted
Posted

Rihanna for the loud and GGGB era bops alone 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Comedor Mentor

Comedor

Posted
Posted

Perfect Duet vs S&M

 

This is the only win for Rihanna. And S&M is not even good.  :michael:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Rafael Rising Star

Rafael

Posted
Posted

As someone already said, Rihanna has put her best songs at #1 while Bey has best ones mostly hidden in her albums or sabotaged by her :skull:

Either way for me, Bey still wins. But it's just personal preference.

 

The Destiny's Child 1-2-3-4 punches :jonny5:

 

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Comedor Mentor

Comedor

Posted
Posted
1 minute ago, Dante said:

"perfect duet" and "savage remix" are such a stain in the rest of her hits :rip: 

Savage Remix is amazing and won a Grammy. Textbook case for how to do a remix.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
TCorey Contributor

TCorey

Posted
Posted

Rihanna has better singles overall than Beyonce.   She actually has one of the more impressive single discographies of anyone.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
blown away Mentor

blown away

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS (this was torture)

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Babydoll. Proficient

Babydoll.

Posted
Posted

Bills, Bills, Bills vs SOS

Say My Name vs Umbrella

Independent Women, Pt. 1 vs Take A Bow

Bootylicious vs Disturbia

Crazy In Love vs Live Your Life

Baby Boy vs Rude Boy (bangers!!!)

Check On It vs Love The Way You Lie

Irreplaceable vs What's My Name?

Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) vs Only Girl (In The World)

Perfect Duet vs S&M

Savage Remix vs We Found Love

BREAK MY SOUL vs Diamonds

TEXAS HOLD 'EM vs The Monster

 

8 for B, 6 for Rih. this ranking is making me realise how much i loveddddddd all of DC's singles like woah

Link to comment
Share on other sites
 Share
Go to topic listing

Obsessed with Pop Culture. Copyright © 1999-2024, ATRL

Navigation

About Us

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.