Acclaimed Posted February 24 Posted February 24 21 minutes ago, Pluto6 said: both literally had 6 minutes each performing their songs, then had their different dance breaks at the end though? No they didn’t. That’s just what they said they had. J.Lo mainly talks about How they had even time, probably to save face. Go watch and count. I read a breakdown of it somewhere. Shakira has about 40 seconds more screen time as I recall. Her songs are played for about 30-40 seconds longer, I think. 1 1
TheBlackBarbie Posted February 24 Posted February 24 16 hours ago, Nippy'sReceipts said: Katy and Rihanna have hits for days such memorable catalogs that it almost doesn’t matter they can’t perform and lip synced and didn’t dance. They relied on visual staging completely Speak for yourself dear. Madge & Beyonce has the catalog and still SLAYED. I mean Madge was 50+ at the time & still managed to put on a better performance than Katy. I'll give Rihanna the benefit of the doubt cause she was pregnant however even if she wasn't, don't think she would have blown the house down. 1
Relampago. Posted February 24 Posted February 24 People unironically dragging Shakira and Jlo are the reason we’re going to get mediocre men performing for the foreseeable future When we get Morgan Wallen next year and then Jay Z the year after, I’ll be sure to take the names in this thread 1 2
shakeyourbombom Posted February 24 Posted February 24 On 2/23/2024 at 10:11 PM, gatito said: shakira the opening act was a waste of everyone's time: she was out of shape, the setlist was a mess and she was outshined by every single artist she shared the stage with Outshined by who sorry? 1
shakeyourbombom Posted February 24 Posted February 24 Delete Shakira’s special guest part She could’ve done her own show, her VMAs performance proved it 1
shakeyourbombom Posted February 24 Posted February 24 On 2/23/2024 at 11:38 PM, Lovett said: Shakira couldn't be bothered to turn the mic on for her performance. Her half of the JLo half-time show can go. Or Gaga tbh. Shakira outsold and outstreamed her counterpart after the show
Mikeymoonshine Posted February 24 Posted February 24 I love Madonna but I didn't care for her halftime show tbh. Katy at least had all those great props and costumes.
Vixen Eyes Posted February 24 Posted February 24 katy's was kind of basic. nothing memorable about it. the others had at least one moment that made them special Madonna had, well.... being Madonna! Beyonce brought back Destiny's Child Gaga sang Born This Way with her whole chest to a crowd of straights + entered the stage out of the air (though she should have switched Million Reasons with either Dancin in Circles, John Wayne, A-Yo or Perfect Illusion. Shakira and JLo put on a fantastic show in their late 40s/early 50s. though my only negative feedback about theirs is that Shakira should have been solo. JLo idk any of her 'hits' beside LDCAT and On the Floor. JLo probably could do a separate superbowl show on her own, but id rather a solo Shakira set. Katy on the other hand pertty much put on a standard tour stop show. 2
shakeyourbombom Posted February 24 Posted February 24 On 2/24/2024 at 2:52 AM, Lovett said: I guess that's the issue – she doesn't rely on those things. They added to her already strong performance. She outperformed. Not her backing dancers. Not her costumes. Not the choreography. Not the pole dancing. JLo. Shakira switched that microphone off and pretended to play guitar. She wasn't bad by any means, but when JLo came on stage it was like the performance came alive. We're talking about this performance. If you can't discuss it and instead want to ramble on about JLo's abysmal streaming numbers, that's your issue. But I'm talking about the Super Bowl performance and that I think JLo completely overshadowed Shakira and out-performed her. Overshowed like how she had ZERO chartings on Spotify US, Spotify Global, Apple Music US and Apple Music Global unlike Shakira?! 1
shakeyourbombom Posted February 24 Posted February 24 21 hours ago, XDNA said: Shakira and JLo should have had their own shows. Maybe Shakira doesn't have enough English hits, but she could invite a guest performer like Pitbull or Ricky Martin to perform a couple songs too. She has enough US hits to do it Her chartings may not be high but she’s more about longevity
DoubleRainbow! Posted February 25 Posted February 25 Not surprised at the results since this site is infested by monsters but the GP prefers Katy's performance over the others
XDNA Posted February 25 Posted February 25 3 hours ago, shakeyourbombom said: She has enough US hits to do it Her chartings may not be high but she’s more about longevity Pop acts perform their biggest songs at the Super Bowl not fan favorites. They can maybe have one sneak but the GeePee want the hits. What would her English set be? 1 1
Smarticle Posted February 25 Posted February 25 Not surprised at the results since this site is infested by OGHs but the GP prefers Gaga's performance over the others 2 4
shakeyourbombom Posted February 25 Posted February 25 3 hours ago, XDNA said: Pop acts perform their biggest songs at the Super Bowl not fan favorites. They can maybe have one sneak but the GeePee want the hits. What would her English set be? There’s no necessary to have an English set. She has enough US hits: Whenever Wherever Hips Don’t Lie She Wolf La Tortura BZRP Music Session Vol.53 TQG Waka Waka (This Time for Africa) Beautiful Liar Chantaje Can’t Remember To Forget You Ballads: Try Everything/ Underneath Your Clothes
Lovett Posted February 25 Posted February 25 11 hours ago, shakeyourbombom said: Shakira outsold and outstreamed her counterpart after the show 8 hours ago, shakeyourbombom said: Overshowed like how she had ZERO chartings on Spotify US, Spotify Global, Apple Music US and Apple Music Global unlike Shakira?! It's wild that you can't actually talk about the performance and are instead talking about streaming services... 1 1
DonnaSpring Posted February 25 Posted February 25 17 hours ago, Sweetness said: I was expecting at least Holiday, Into the groove but we got Express Yourself and Vogue, I know technically they were more successful on the charts but more people are probably more familar with those two and it fit the event, the other two did not. Into the groove isn't even a single in the US and wasn't a hit and holiday only peaked at 16 , why on earth would she every include those on a super bowl show?! 1
teenager Posted February 25 Posted February 25 I actually love them all - of course they have their shortcomings but from personal preference I guess I’d have to say Madonna just for the LMFAO/GMAYL segment I abstain and pick Rihanna x
XDNA Posted February 25 Posted February 25 (edited) 2 hours ago, shakeyourbombom said: There’s no necessary to have an English set. She has enough US hits: Whenever Wherever Hips Don’t Lie She Wolf La Tortura BZRP Music Session Vol.53 TQG Waka Waka (This Time for Africa) Beautiful Liar Chantaje Can’t Remember To Forget You Ballads: Try Everything/ Underneath Your Clothes Some of those songs came out after she did the Super Bowl which proves my point that she didn't have enough hits in the US for a solo show. And a couple songs were not hits or forgotten in the US. Edited February 25 by XDNA 1
shakeyourbombom Posted February 25 Posted February 25 1 hour ago, XDNA said: Some of those songs came out after she did the Super Bowl which proves my point that she didn't have enough hits in the US for a solo show. And a couple songs were not hits or forgotten in the US. Delusional, right now we are talking about if Shakira is given a solo show then will she get enough US hits. The answer is yes. She proved it in the 2020 SuperBowl and VMAs 2023. Her perfomer status is already well enough to take her to the SuperBowl stage. 1
shakeyourbombom Posted February 25 Posted February 25 4 hours ago, Lovett said: It's wild that you can't actually talk about the performance and are instead talking about streaming services... That says a lot which performance the audience cared and enjoyed about.
Lovett Posted February 25 Posted February 25 1 minute ago, shakeyourbombom said: That says a lot which performance the audience cared and enjoyed about. That's wonderful for 'the audience'. I'm sharing my opinion, not trying to speak for other people as if I'm aware of how they all felt as well. 2 1
XDNA Posted February 25 Posted February 25 7 minutes ago, shakeyourbombom said: Delusional, right now we are talking about if Shakira is given a solo show then will she get enough US hits. The answer is yes. She proved it in the 2020 SuperBowl and VMAs 2023. Her perfomer status is already well enough to take her to the SuperBowl stage. Why do you keep posting that list as some kind of gotcha? iTunes has been so insignificant for years now. It's very easily manipulated by fanbases since there's so little activity there than in its hey day. And including songs and albums that didn't even place top 40 is like a self-drag. I don't know where you're from but MTV and the VMAs stopped being relevant like a decade or more ago too. 1
shakeyourbombom Posted February 25 Posted February 25 2 minutes ago, Lovett said: That's wonderful for 'the audience'. I'm sharing my opinion, not trying to speak for other people as if I'm aware of how they all felt as well. So I’m sharing my opinion too. Anything wrong?
Recommended Posts