base talk Destiny's Child vs Spice Girls vs TLC vs Girls Aloud

[JonginBey]

Destiny’s Child for both.

[itsmagic]

Girls Aloud and Destiny's Child all the way. TLC had some great singles, and Spice Girls are great for a throwback, but I don't listen to them too often.

[Yelero]

[HïFidelity]

Albums

 

1. TLC

2. Destiny’s Child

3. Spice Girls

singles (videos)

 

1. TLC

2. Spice Girls

3. Destiny’s Child

 

TLC’s albums are like unbeatable. FanMail has some of the most intricately complicated production that makes it a standard in pop / R&B.

 

the funniest thing about this comparison is the Spice Girls entire career basically happened while TLC were on hiatus between CrazySexyCool and FanMail (1995-1999). By the time FanMail got released, the spice girls were basically a recent memory.

[HïFidelity]

1 hour ago, Yelero said:

I know this particular show played in the Spice World movie but was this an actual show ? Peak spice girls image wise tbh

Edited January 24 by HïFidelity

[Phaunzie]

Girls Aloud for both.

[ICLDXU4HS]

DC / TLC > Spice Girls >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> GA

[BraveNewSeth]

GA for both

 

TLC and DC are pretty much tied. They each have one great album and the others are trash/single heavy. SG have some of the worst albums I’ve ever heard. 

[Jooj]

Girls Aloud > TLC

 

Im not familiar with either Spice Girls or Destiny's Child aside from their hits so i cant rank them 

[KanMap]

TLC >>>>

[Lovett]

I love all of them tbh, but probably TLC the least. I only know their hits.

[yamiyuuuu]

Erm... One of these things is not like the others 

 

TLC wins on the albums department with CrazySexyCool alone 

Destiny's Child for singles 

[allforyou]

In terms of albums they all have good stuff but my favorites are the Spice Girls', their first two are excellence

 

Regarding singles Destiny's Child and the Spice Girls have some fantastic releases but Girls Aloud's are pop perfection so them

[sweetheart]

Spices anthem legend

(Just bc Victoria Secret still biggest power girls Legendary btw) 

[Titanbaddie]

Bills Bills Bills -  1

Bug a Boo - 33

Say my Name - 1

Jumpin Jumpin - 3

Independent Woman - 1

Survivor - 2 

Bootylicious - 1

Emotions - 10

Lose My Breath - 3

Soldier - 3

 

Is an actually insane and iconic singles run

 

[B-Luke]

TLC for both and CrazySexyCool is the best album between all of them.

[Feanor]

Destiny's Child for both.

[davidson]

Spice Girls of course 

[Yakult]

Destiny’s Child > TLC > Girls Aloud >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Spice Girls

 

Emma Bunton was already onto her second solo album by the time I got into music as a kid. Spice Girls image/branding is iconic, but bar half a dozen singles their music sounds dated/embarrassing to me.

 

CrazySexyCool is one of the best records of the 90s & Girls Aloud have a killer singles run. DC have the best combination of great singles & albums though.

[mons†er]

it’s not even a question. 

[PMKARDASHIAN]

Spice Girls > TLC > Destiny’s Child 

 

The girl groups of the 10s could NEVER 

[ReachOut]

Spice Girls >>>>>>