poll Plastic Hearts (Miley) vs If I Can't Have Love, I Want Power (Halsey)

[Diesel is Desire]

 

[unino]

the listenable one.

[Diesel is Desire]

9 minutes ago, unino said:

the listenable one.

So both

[unino]

Just now, Taeyong said:

So both

yes if your ears are already permanently damaged.

[Kimi]

Plastic hearts is kinda good tbh the other one I didn’t bother to listen second time 

[The Music Industry]

Halsey clears 

[CottageHore]

It’s not even close. PH by a landslide. Halsey wins for the album art, though.

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Plastic Heart is a masterpiece.

[Miichael]

IICHL is good but Plastic Hearts devours

[NordicGuy]

Both are great albums. Plastic Hearts is the more consistent album with every song being at least an 8/10 so it got my vote but to be honest songs like You asked for this and Girls Is a Gun are better than anything Miley has ever made. Unfortunately the weaker moments really drag Halsey's album down.

[honestopinion]

Plastic hearts easily wins at everything 

[West Coast]

Miley for ALL

 

[Johnny Jacobs]

Midnight skies > Halsey no shade 

[Reverse Warholian]

I find IICHLIWP to be more fresh, inventive, with superior lyrics, melodies, production, and art direction, embodying a more contemporary rock album vibe compared to PH which feels like a scrapbook pastiche of past trope-y pop-rock sounds and aesthetics. Miley's vocals are addictive though and elevate the material tremendously. Nonetheless, I still enjoy both albums. Weird comparison. 

Edited January 6 by Reverse Warholian

[MusicLoverDude]

Miley for everything except the album cover, Halsey slayed that just a bit more.

[The Man Who]

I haven’t listened to that Halsey album yet but I can feel it in my prostate that she doesn’t have any songs as excellent as Midnight Sky, Angels Like You or Night Crawling on there.

 

[fa77ot]

Miley, sweetie

[TalkThatRihanna]

I find Plastic Hearts to be more fresh, inventive, with superior lyrics, melodies, production, and art direction, embodying a more contemporary rock album vibe compared to IICHLIWP which feels like a scrapbook pastiche of past trope-y pop-rock sounds and aesthetics. Miley's vocals are addictive though and elevate the material tremendously. Nonetheless, I only enjoyed Plastic Hearts. Great comparison. 

[ZeroPoint]

Halsey I’m so sorry that none of these old queens have taste 

[4Real]

I prefer Halsey's even if it has some boring filler

[thatsmydemi]

Miley's is more accessible (basically made for radio) but Halsey's is more interesting. 

 

 

[Achilles.]

Halsey’s is my third favorite album of the decade and I never liked anything from her before it dropped. I switched like a…

 

Plastic Hearts is also top 10, or at least close to it. Easily Miley’s best effort and solid from start to finish. 

[Mocha]

halsey's is a great album, but I don't like all of its tracks whereas I don't skip a single song on PH

 

 

[crf13]

Plastic Classic for all

[TensionThingz]

Classics plastified outsold