base talk Erotica vs. ARTPOP, both underperformed, but which had more artistry?

[crf13]

Erotica, sweetie, I'm so sorry... 

[DR0GO]

Delete this.

[TensionThingz]

Erótica >>>>>>>>>Gaga entire catalog

[MadMax12]

Erotica was classy sexual with the visuals, singles, sex book and integrity. ARTPOP was more try hard and way too early in her career to be taking these risks 

[ohwow]

erotica sweetie

[Soda Pop Queen]

I like Artpop but this thread is a joke. It's not even in the same realm as Erotica.

[Lover]

i'm not sure

[Raptus]

11 hours ago, Chris said:

Artpop does not have impact or artistry.

But, but, but the FLYING Dress!!!

 

[Raptus]

6 hours ago, MadMax12 said:

Erotica was classy sexual with the visuals, singles, sex book and integrity.

Edited December 30, 2023 by Raptus

[Jjang]

are we really doing this…

[Dark Miracles]

 

Gaga wishes but she can't!

[40000000000000]

gaga doesn't have ONE song in her discography that can compete with erotica. not one.

[Raptus]

2 hours ago, 40000000000000 said:

gaga doesn't have ONE song in her discography that can compete with erotica. not one.

Sexxx Dreams is her erotica... kinda

 

[GlamSlam]

19 hours ago, Jay07 said:

The fact that 30 years later, Erotica has aged like fine wine, the public has reappraised how daring and forward thinking it was and it is the centerpiece of Madonna's current tour and 10 years later, not even Gaga claims the disaster that ended her pop career called ARTPOP.

 

[suburbannature]

The one with Rain

[TipToe]

8 hours ago, Lover said:

i'm not sure

It's tough, isn't it? I mean the alberm that has the absolute gem that is Mary Jane Hoollands really makes us wonder if artpop could mean anything? I applaud GaGa for the effort.

[AMIT]

I think ATRL does a bit much on ARTPOP sometimes (better than Chrom! ), but still Erotica, sweetie...